 |
| 1970 |
Carmine 'Turi' Franzese was a Soldier in the Colombo Family.
A loanshark and close associate of Bonanno leader Joseph Massino, Franzese was part of the first group inducted into the Colombo Family after the books were re-opened in 1976.
His uncle John 'Sonny' Franzese (1917-2020) served as the Family's Underboss during the mid-2000s.
Another uncle, Sonny's older brother Onofrio, was a reputed vicious killer with links to both the Colombos and Bonannos.
Grandfather and namesake Carmine 'Turi the Lion' Franzese (1881-1957) was a Possible Member with early links to the local Camorra.
Several other relatives have been connected with the Colombos.
Carmine was born January 25, 1932 at 348 Leonard St in Williamsburg, Brooklyn to Michael and Grace Cosgrove. Father from Palma Campania comune of Naples, Campania.
The Franzeses resided at the same address.
Within a couple of years they left Williamsburg for the neighborhood of Flatbush, residing at 19 Oakland Place. Michael worked as a store clerk.
On April 6, 1949 seventeen-year-old Carmine was arrested by the New York Police Department's 87th Precinct in Brooklyn on charges of burglary and possessing burglar tools. Convicted and given an indefinite probation term.
By April 1950 the Franzeses moved to 58 Dupont St in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Much of Carmine's known criminal activity in the following decades would be centered in this neighborhood.
A loanshark and close associate of Bonanno leader Joseph Massino, Franzese was part of the first group inducted into the Colombo Family after the books were re-opened in 1976.
His uncle John 'Sonny' Franzese (1917-2020) served as the Family's Underboss during the mid-2000s.
Another uncle, Sonny's older brother Onofrio, was a reputed vicious killer with links to both the Colombos and Bonannos.
Grandfather and namesake Carmine 'Turi the Lion' Franzese (1881-1957) was a Possible Member with early links to the local Camorra.
Several other relatives have been connected with the Colombos.
Carmine was born January 25, 1932 at 348 Leonard St in Williamsburg, Brooklyn to Michael and Grace Cosgrove. Father from Palma Campania comune of Naples, Campania.
The Franzeses resided at the same address.
Within a couple of years they left Williamsburg for the neighborhood of Flatbush, residing at 19 Oakland Place. Michael worked as a store clerk.
On April 6, 1949 seventeen-year-old Carmine was arrested by the New York Police Department's 87th Precinct in Brooklyn on charges of burglary and possessing burglar tools. Convicted and given an indefinite probation term.
By April 1950 the Franzeses moved to 58 Dupont St in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Much of Carmine's known criminal activity in the following decades would be centered in this neighborhood.
 |
| J. Franzese (L) and S. Musacchio Franzese Photo: FBN Mafia Book |
By 1958 he was likely-on record with his uncle Sonny Franzese, a Colombo Soldier reporting to Salvatore 'Sally Sheik' Musacchio.
Among Sonny's closest associates was fellow Musacchio crew member Joseph 'Little Joey' Brancato. Over the following years Brancato would also develop a tight relationship with Carmine.
On February 16, 1959 arrested by NYPD 83rd Pct Brooklyn.
On March 18, 1960 Carmine, his uncle Sonny and Joseph Brancato were present when the NYPD raided a card game on New Utrecht Ave.
Called before Grand Jury investigating local gambling, the trio refused to answer questions and were indicted on criminal contempt late the following month. Carmine ultimately pleaded guilty and received six months at Rikers Island.
On May 16, 1960 Sonny and Carmine attended the testimonial dinner for Local 164 President Charles Browne at the Town and Country Club in Marine Park, Brooklyn.
Around June 5, 1961 Carmine began serving his six month contempt sentence at Rikers.
By December 1961 he was released and, with Colombo Associate Vincent 'Big Lou' Russo, handling Sonny's policy action.
Around the middle of July 1962 Sonny was promoted to official Captain.
Made members of Franzese's crew included Anthony 'Gawk' Augello, Joseph Brancato, Fred 'Freddie Red' DeLucia, Dominick 'Mimi' Scialo and Joseph 'Jo Jo' Vitacco.
Associates included Dominic 'Little Dom' Cataldo, Carmine Franzese, John 'Johnny Irish' Matera, Salvatore 'Sonny Black' Montello and many others.
Carmine was then operating the Yukon Luncheonette at the Rockdale Housing Development in Queens.
He was also overseeing numbers and loansharking at the Shaefer Brewery and, one informant noted, was 'always looking for an opportunity to expand'.
That Fall, Sonny Franzese backed Carmine and an Unsub in opening the Jam Session afterhours club in Greenpoint. An informant reported: "Gambling and prostitution activities take place at this location. Allegedly, this operation is losing money and will soon close. Tuttie Franzese was described as a protégé of Sonny [and] had been kept under wraps until approximately six weeks ago when he apparently was told that he could do anything he wanted to."
By 1963 resided at 103 Knickerbocker Ave in Bushwick.
On January 22, 1964 pleaded guilty in Brooklyn Supreme Court to a criminal contempt charge.
On June 19, 1965 Colombo Soldier Joseph Brancato was surveilled by the Nassau County PD visiting an office Carmine maintained at 265 W 55th St in Midtown Manhattan.
By the following summer operated Alto Taping Company from his residence in Bushwick.
In November 1968 an informant reported that Sonny Franzese used Carmine as a 'strong arm man'.
In February 1970 an informant identified a photograph of Carmine as a close associate of Brooklyn bookmaker John D'Angelo.
The following month Sonny Franzese was remanded to Manhattan's Federal House of Detention to begin a fifty year sentence for bank robbery conspiracy.
Among Sonny's closest associates was fellow Musacchio crew member Joseph 'Little Joey' Brancato. Over the following years Brancato would also develop a tight relationship with Carmine.
On February 16, 1959 arrested by NYPD 83rd Pct Brooklyn.
On March 18, 1960 Carmine, his uncle Sonny and Joseph Brancato were present when the NYPD raided a card game on New Utrecht Ave.
Called before Grand Jury investigating local gambling, the trio refused to answer questions and were indicted on criminal contempt late the following month. Carmine ultimately pleaded guilty and received six months at Rikers Island.
On May 16, 1960 Sonny and Carmine attended the testimonial dinner for Local 164 President Charles Browne at the Town and Country Club in Marine Park, Brooklyn.
Around June 5, 1961 Carmine began serving his six month contempt sentence at Rikers.
By December 1961 he was released and, with Colombo Associate Vincent 'Big Lou' Russo, handling Sonny's policy action.
Around the middle of July 1962 Sonny was promoted to official Captain.
Made members of Franzese's crew included Anthony 'Gawk' Augello, Joseph Brancato, Fred 'Freddie Red' DeLucia, Dominick 'Mimi' Scialo and Joseph 'Jo Jo' Vitacco.
Associates included Dominic 'Little Dom' Cataldo, Carmine Franzese, John 'Johnny Irish' Matera, Salvatore 'Sonny Black' Montello and many others.
Carmine was then operating the Yukon Luncheonette at the Rockdale Housing Development in Queens.
He was also overseeing numbers and loansharking at the Shaefer Brewery and, one informant noted, was 'always looking for an opportunity to expand'.
That Fall, Sonny Franzese backed Carmine and an Unsub in opening the Jam Session afterhours club in Greenpoint. An informant reported: "Gambling and prostitution activities take place at this location. Allegedly, this operation is losing money and will soon close. Tuttie Franzese was described as a protégé of Sonny [and] had been kept under wraps until approximately six weeks ago when he apparently was told that he could do anything he wanted to."
By 1963 resided at 103 Knickerbocker Ave in Bushwick.
On January 22, 1964 pleaded guilty in Brooklyn Supreme Court to a criminal contempt charge.
On June 19, 1965 Colombo Soldier Joseph Brancato was surveilled by the Nassau County PD visiting an office Carmine maintained at 265 W 55th St in Midtown Manhattan.
By the following summer operated Alto Taping Company from his residence in Bushwick.
In November 1968 an informant reported that Sonny Franzese used Carmine as a 'strong arm man'.
In February 1970 an informant identified a photograph of Carmine as a close associate of Brooklyn bookmaker John D'Angelo.
The following month Sonny Franzese was remanded to Manhattan's Federal House of Detention to begin a fifty year sentence for bank robbery conspiracy.
 |
| J. Brancato (L) and D. Scialo Brancato Photo: New York Daily News |
Informants initially reported that Dominick 'Mimi' Scialo, who had previously served as Franzese's Acting Captain, would take over the crew's activities.
Within the year Joseph Brancato was confirmed as the Acting Captain while Franzese appealed his sentence.
On April 24, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised recently he had heard an individual named Tuttie Franzese had taken over the operation of John Franzese. He believed this operation taken over by Tutti only consisted of that operation which extended into New York City. He believed possibly this same Tuttie Franzese was related to John Franzese and may be a nephew.”
By early 1971 subject of an FBI gambling investigation. He was then residing in at 67-71 54th Ave in Maspeth, Queens and frequenting a social club on Union St in Brooklyn.
On September 13, 1971 Sonny Franzese arrived at the Federal House of Detention in Manhattan from USP Leavenworth. Visitors over the next couple of weeks included Carmine Franzese and Acting Captain Joseph Brancato.
On December 9, 1971 Carmine, Colombo Soldier Modesto 'Duke' Santoro and Colombo Associate Lazzaro SanGiovanni were indicted by the US Attorney's Office in Manhattan on charges of conspiracy, extortion, forgery and grand larceny. Accused of extorting the Mobil Oil Corporation, the trio were released on $10,000 bail each.
On March 13, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Carmine Franzese] frequents Dee Dee's Coffee Shop, 432 Leonard Street, operated by Sonny Franzese's [redacted] and [redacted] John 'Murphy' Fencerilla. This place was once an after hours joint frequented by Joseph Brancato and Joseph Vitacco, both members of the Colombo Family." (Fencerilla was another uncle of Carmine's; he married one of Sonny's younger sisters.)
In late April 1972 Joseph Brancato was named the Colombo Family's Acting Boss.
Franzese was by then one of Brancato's closest associates and the two were frequently observed by law enforcement.
On June 8, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that (Colombo Associate Vincent) Lou Russo, 420 Graham Avenue, a close associate of Tuttie Franzese, did time in Danbury Federal Prison several years ago with Franzese, and Russo is still annoyed because Franzese did not do the right thing while Russo was in jail."
Around June 1972 Franzese accompanied Acting Boss Joseph Brancato to meet Colombo Soldier Sebastiano 'Buster' Aloi in Florida. The pair sought Aloi's help with resolving a dispute between crew member Joseph Vitacco and Genovese Member Frank 'Funzi' Tieri over a $2,500 numbers bet.
By Fall 1972 Brancato had left the Acting Boss position and continued running the Franzese crew as Acting Captain.
On January 16, 1973 Brancato, Franzese, Colombo Associate Vincent Russo and Unsub observed by FBI inside Dedes Corner Restaurant at Jackson and Leonard Sts in Williamsburg.
Eight days later Agents observed Brancato, Franzese and four Unsubs at Dedes.
On February 27, 1973 Brancato, Franzese and two Unsubs were observed on Havemeyer St in Williamsburg.
On May 14, 1973 Brancato, Franzese and an Unsub were observed seated together inside Ferrara's Pastry Shop at 195 Grand St in Little Italy, Manhattan. The Unsub received a phone call at the business, after which Franzese and Brancato were followed and subsequently lost while driving toward Mulberry St. (Ferrara's was a hangout for Sebastian Aloi and his son Vincent, a Family Captain.)
On July 16, 1973 FBI surveillance conducted on social club at 7716 18th Ave in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. Over the space of an hour the club was visited by Brancato, Franzese, Colombo Underboss Anthony 'Abby' Abbatemarco, Consigliere Alphonse 'Allie Boy' Persico, Captain Charles 'Charlie Moose' Panarella, Soldier Modesto Santoro and Associates Nicholas 'Nicky Black' Grancio and Thomas 'Shorty' Spero. (Robert 'Bobby Bad Heart' Perrette, later a Bonanno Captain, was spotted driving by the club.)
On July 26, 1973 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa provided an update on the Colombo Family's structure and the activities of various members. Scarpa identified Joseph Brancato as the official Captain of the former Franzese crew and named Carmine Franzese and others as Associates.
[Link]
On August 20, 1973 Brancato's wife was waked in Middle Village, Queens. Attendees in addition to Franzese included Colombo Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Consigliere Alphonse Persico, Captain Charles Panarella and Soldiers Frank 'Gandy' LoCicero, Rosario 'Black Sam' Nastasa, Modesto Santoro and Joseph Vitacco.
On September 21, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he attended the wake for Joseph Brancato's wife, and while discussing Brancato with Tuttie Franzese was advised by Franzese that Brancato is moving up in the Colombo Family and is definitely slated to take over the Colombo Family."
In November 1973 Franzese and Modesto Santoro began standing trial in Manhattan on the Mobil Oil extortion indictment.
The same month the Judge ruled that the Government had failed to prove its case and dismissed the indictment. The charges against severed co-defendant Lazzaro SanGiovanni were later thrown out as well.
On December 26, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Felice Vizzari, an inactive shylock, is claiming Joseph Brancato does not want to help Sonny Franzese get out of jail. He also claims Sonny's cousin (sic) Tootie Franzese sides with Brancato."
On January 17, 1974 Franzese, Colombo Associate Joseph 'Joe Lane' Gentile and others were observed at the Diplomat Lounge, a Colombo hangout at 3rd Ave and Carroll St in Gowanus. An informant noted: "At the same time the following were meeting around the corner at Monte’s Restaurant, reportedly with two cops (identities unknown): Anthony Abbatemarco, Joe Brancato, Alphonse Persico.”
On January 28, 1974 FBI surveillance conducted on Joy Lounge at 369-371 43rd St in Sunset Park, Brooklyn. Those observed included Colombo Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato and Associates Salvatore 'Sally' Albanese, Carmine Franzese, Theodore 'Teddy' Persico, Andrew Russo and Thomas Scuderi.
Two days later the FBI surveilled a meeting held inside Grotta D'Oro Italian Restaurant at 691 Flatbush Ave in East Flatbush, Brooklyn. Those present were Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato, Soldier Paul D'Amico, Soldier Vincent 'Jimmy' Muce and Associates Salvatore Albanese and Carmine Franzese. (Photographs were taken of this meeting but have since been lost.)
On May 30, 1974 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa provided an update on the Colombo Family structure. He identified Joseph Brancato as the official Captain of the former Franzese crew and named Carmine Franzese and others as Associates.
On July 11, 1974 the FBI surveilled a meeting at Hoffbrau's Restaurant at 9406 4th Ave in Bay Ridge. Those present were Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato, Soldier Leonard Dello and Associates Salvatore Albanese and Carmine Franzese. (The following day DiBella surrendered to begin serving a Federal sentence for contempt. Abbatemarco was temporarily designated Acting Boss.)
The same day an informant identified Brancato as a Colombo Captain frequently seen in the company of Carmine Franzese, 'who is not a made guy but is well respected by the wiseguys'.
Late the following month Brancato replaced Abbatemarco as Acting Boss.
By September 1974 Carmine resided at 51-38 69th St in Maspeth. Listed employment with Mopal Constructing Corporation at 815 McLean Ave in Yonkers.
Likely due to his close relationship with Brancato, Carmine's residence was subject to heightened FBI surveillance over the following months.
On September 10 Franzese drove Brancato to a meeting with Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco and Associate Salvatore Albanese at Crisci's Restaurant in Williamsburg.
The following day Abbatemarco, Brancato and Franzese were followed to various locations in Brooklyn and Manhattan.
On September 12, 1974 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa (Colombo Soldier) reported: "[Scarpa] advised that he took part in a dinner at the Blueprint 100 Restaurant early this week at which all the other Colombo Captains and close associates attended including Joe Brancato, Anthony Abbatemarco, Teddy Persico, Andrew Russo, [Redacted], Tutti Franzese, and others. Bill paid by Joe Brancato came to over $1,000."
On September 24, 1974 FBI CI reported: "[CI] stated ‘Tuttie’ Franzese is connected with Local 6A, and also acts as a ‘trouble shooter’ for Brancato. The informant advised the lower echelon crew members report to ‘Tuttie’ or get his clearance for a meet with Brancato. ‘Tuttie’ also acts as driver and bodyguard for Joe B."
On October 10, 1974 Franzese met with Brancato at Timm Trucking in Bushwick, where the latter ostensibly worked as a dispatcher.
On October 18, 1974 an informant described Franzese as Brancato's 'go between' with Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, who had recently had his car bugged and was facing a Federal Grand Jury investigation.
In November 1974 designated subject of FBI anti-racketeering investigation.
On November 18, 1974 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised [Abbatemarco] continues to maintain a low profile and doesn’t leave the house too much other than to see his attorney or for medical reasons..The informant advised two weeks ago on a Monday, Tuttie Franzese visited with Abbatemarco at his residence and does so periodically as ‘go between’ for Brancato and Abbatemarco.”
On February 8, 1975 Colombo Soldier and Brancato crew member Joseph Vitacco married. Reception held at the Family-controlled Queens Terrace Caterers in Woodside, Queens. Attendees included Acting Boss Joseph Brancato, Brancato's Acting Captain Rosario Nastasa and Carmine Franzese.
The following month an FBI CI noted that Vitacco's Jay Vee Lounge in Bushwick was used by Carmine as a weekly meeting spot for his loansharking operation.
On February 28, 1975 Brancato, Franzese and several crew members attended a benefit for singer Vic Roma at the Hollywood Terrace in Bensonhurst.
On March 28, 1975 an FBI CI reported that Brancato and Franzese met with Lucchese Member Vincent 'Vinny Beans' Foceri. (By September 1977 Foceri was the Consigliere).
Beginning in late April 1975 Colombo Associate Salvatore 'Sonny Black' Montello, a longtime Franzese crew associate, was interviewed by the FBI and provided an extensive narrative of his time with the Colombos. He named Carmine Franzese as a fellow crew member and active participant in the early 1960s Profaci - Gallo conflict.
Within the year Joseph Brancato was confirmed as the Acting Captain while Franzese appealed his sentence.
On April 24, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised recently he had heard an individual named Tuttie Franzese had taken over the operation of John Franzese. He believed this operation taken over by Tutti only consisted of that operation which extended into New York City. He believed possibly this same Tuttie Franzese was related to John Franzese and may be a nephew.”
By early 1971 subject of an FBI gambling investigation. He was then residing in at 67-71 54th Ave in Maspeth, Queens and frequenting a social club on Union St in Brooklyn.
On September 13, 1971 Sonny Franzese arrived at the Federal House of Detention in Manhattan from USP Leavenworth. Visitors over the next couple of weeks included Carmine Franzese and Acting Captain Joseph Brancato.
On December 9, 1971 Carmine, Colombo Soldier Modesto 'Duke' Santoro and Colombo Associate Lazzaro SanGiovanni were indicted by the US Attorney's Office in Manhattan on charges of conspiracy, extortion, forgery and grand larceny. Accused of extorting the Mobil Oil Corporation, the trio were released on $10,000 bail each.
On March 13, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Carmine Franzese] frequents Dee Dee's Coffee Shop, 432 Leonard Street, operated by Sonny Franzese's [redacted] and [redacted] John 'Murphy' Fencerilla. This place was once an after hours joint frequented by Joseph Brancato and Joseph Vitacco, both members of the Colombo Family." (Fencerilla was another uncle of Carmine's; he married one of Sonny's younger sisters.)
In late April 1972 Joseph Brancato was named the Colombo Family's Acting Boss.
Franzese was by then one of Brancato's closest associates and the two were frequently observed by law enforcement.
On June 8, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that (Colombo Associate Vincent) Lou Russo, 420 Graham Avenue, a close associate of Tuttie Franzese, did time in Danbury Federal Prison several years ago with Franzese, and Russo is still annoyed because Franzese did not do the right thing while Russo was in jail."
Around June 1972 Franzese accompanied Acting Boss Joseph Brancato to meet Colombo Soldier Sebastiano 'Buster' Aloi in Florida. The pair sought Aloi's help with resolving a dispute between crew member Joseph Vitacco and Genovese Member Frank 'Funzi' Tieri over a $2,500 numbers bet.
By Fall 1972 Brancato had left the Acting Boss position and continued running the Franzese crew as Acting Captain.
On January 16, 1973 Brancato, Franzese, Colombo Associate Vincent Russo and Unsub observed by FBI inside Dedes Corner Restaurant at Jackson and Leonard Sts in Williamsburg.
Eight days later Agents observed Brancato, Franzese and four Unsubs at Dedes.
On February 27, 1973 Brancato, Franzese and two Unsubs were observed on Havemeyer St in Williamsburg.
On May 14, 1973 Brancato, Franzese and an Unsub were observed seated together inside Ferrara's Pastry Shop at 195 Grand St in Little Italy, Manhattan. The Unsub received a phone call at the business, after which Franzese and Brancato were followed and subsequently lost while driving toward Mulberry St. (Ferrara's was a hangout for Sebastian Aloi and his son Vincent, a Family Captain.)
On July 16, 1973 FBI surveillance conducted on social club at 7716 18th Ave in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. Over the space of an hour the club was visited by Brancato, Franzese, Colombo Underboss Anthony 'Abby' Abbatemarco, Consigliere Alphonse 'Allie Boy' Persico, Captain Charles 'Charlie Moose' Panarella, Soldier Modesto Santoro and Associates Nicholas 'Nicky Black' Grancio and Thomas 'Shorty' Spero. (Robert 'Bobby Bad Heart' Perrette, later a Bonanno Captain, was spotted driving by the club.)
On July 26, 1973 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa provided an update on the Colombo Family's structure and the activities of various members. Scarpa identified Joseph Brancato as the official Captain of the former Franzese crew and named Carmine Franzese and others as Associates.
[Link]
On August 20, 1973 Brancato's wife was waked in Middle Village, Queens. Attendees in addition to Franzese included Colombo Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Consigliere Alphonse Persico, Captain Charles Panarella and Soldiers Frank 'Gandy' LoCicero, Rosario 'Black Sam' Nastasa, Modesto Santoro and Joseph Vitacco.
On September 21, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he attended the wake for Joseph Brancato's wife, and while discussing Brancato with Tuttie Franzese was advised by Franzese that Brancato is moving up in the Colombo Family and is definitely slated to take over the Colombo Family."
In November 1973 Franzese and Modesto Santoro began standing trial in Manhattan on the Mobil Oil extortion indictment.
The same month the Judge ruled that the Government had failed to prove its case and dismissed the indictment. The charges against severed co-defendant Lazzaro SanGiovanni were later thrown out as well.
On December 26, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Felice Vizzari, an inactive shylock, is claiming Joseph Brancato does not want to help Sonny Franzese get out of jail. He also claims Sonny's cousin (sic) Tootie Franzese sides with Brancato."
On January 17, 1974 Franzese, Colombo Associate Joseph 'Joe Lane' Gentile and others were observed at the Diplomat Lounge, a Colombo hangout at 3rd Ave and Carroll St in Gowanus. An informant noted: "At the same time the following were meeting around the corner at Monte’s Restaurant, reportedly with two cops (identities unknown): Anthony Abbatemarco, Joe Brancato, Alphonse Persico.”
On January 28, 1974 FBI surveillance conducted on Joy Lounge at 369-371 43rd St in Sunset Park, Brooklyn. Those observed included Colombo Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato and Associates Salvatore 'Sally' Albanese, Carmine Franzese, Theodore 'Teddy' Persico, Andrew Russo and Thomas Scuderi.
Two days later the FBI surveilled a meeting held inside Grotta D'Oro Italian Restaurant at 691 Flatbush Ave in East Flatbush, Brooklyn. Those present were Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato, Soldier Paul D'Amico, Soldier Vincent 'Jimmy' Muce and Associates Salvatore Albanese and Carmine Franzese. (Photographs were taken of this meeting but have since been lost.)
On May 30, 1974 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa provided an update on the Colombo Family structure. He identified Joseph Brancato as the official Captain of the former Franzese crew and named Carmine Franzese and others as Associates.
On July 11, 1974 the FBI surveilled a meeting at Hoffbrau's Restaurant at 9406 4th Ave in Bay Ridge. Those present were Boss Thomas DiBella, Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, Captain Joseph Brancato, Soldier Leonard Dello and Associates Salvatore Albanese and Carmine Franzese. (The following day DiBella surrendered to begin serving a Federal sentence for contempt. Abbatemarco was temporarily designated Acting Boss.)
The same day an informant identified Brancato as a Colombo Captain frequently seen in the company of Carmine Franzese, 'who is not a made guy but is well respected by the wiseguys'.
Late the following month Brancato replaced Abbatemarco as Acting Boss.
By September 1974 Carmine resided at 51-38 69th St in Maspeth. Listed employment with Mopal Constructing Corporation at 815 McLean Ave in Yonkers.
Likely due to his close relationship with Brancato, Carmine's residence was subject to heightened FBI surveillance over the following months.
On September 10 Franzese drove Brancato to a meeting with Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco and Associate Salvatore Albanese at Crisci's Restaurant in Williamsburg.
The following day Abbatemarco, Brancato and Franzese were followed to various locations in Brooklyn and Manhattan.
On September 12, 1974 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa (Colombo Soldier) reported: "[Scarpa] advised that he took part in a dinner at the Blueprint 100 Restaurant early this week at which all the other Colombo Captains and close associates attended including Joe Brancato, Anthony Abbatemarco, Teddy Persico, Andrew Russo, [Redacted], Tutti Franzese, and others. Bill paid by Joe Brancato came to over $1,000."
On September 24, 1974 FBI CI reported: "[CI] stated ‘Tuttie’ Franzese is connected with Local 6A, and also acts as a ‘trouble shooter’ for Brancato. The informant advised the lower echelon crew members report to ‘Tuttie’ or get his clearance for a meet with Brancato. ‘Tuttie’ also acts as driver and bodyguard for Joe B."
On October 10, 1974 Franzese met with Brancato at Timm Trucking in Bushwick, where the latter ostensibly worked as a dispatcher.
On October 18, 1974 an informant described Franzese as Brancato's 'go between' with Underboss Anthony Abbatemarco, who had recently had his car bugged and was facing a Federal Grand Jury investigation.
In November 1974 designated subject of FBI anti-racketeering investigation.
On November 18, 1974 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised [Abbatemarco] continues to maintain a low profile and doesn’t leave the house too much other than to see his attorney or for medical reasons..The informant advised two weeks ago on a Monday, Tuttie Franzese visited with Abbatemarco at his residence and does so periodically as ‘go between’ for Brancato and Abbatemarco.”
On February 8, 1975 Colombo Soldier and Brancato crew member Joseph Vitacco married. Reception held at the Family-controlled Queens Terrace Caterers in Woodside, Queens. Attendees included Acting Boss Joseph Brancato, Brancato's Acting Captain Rosario Nastasa and Carmine Franzese.
The following month an FBI CI noted that Vitacco's Jay Vee Lounge in Bushwick was used by Carmine as a weekly meeting spot for his loansharking operation.
On February 28, 1975 Brancato, Franzese and several crew members attended a benefit for singer Vic Roma at the Hollywood Terrace in Bensonhurst.
On March 28, 1975 an FBI CI reported that Brancato and Franzese met with Lucchese Member Vincent 'Vinny Beans' Foceri. (By September 1977 Foceri was the Consigliere).
Beginning in late April 1975 Colombo Associate Salvatore 'Sonny Black' Montello, a longtime Franzese crew associate, was interviewed by the FBI and provided an extensive narrative of his time with the Colombos. He named Carmine Franzese as a fellow crew member and active participant in the early 1960s Profaci - Gallo conflict.
 |
| A. Maione |
On May 28, 1975 Montello reported:
"
"
[Joseph] Brancato is a shylock's shylock and he never makes shylock loans to victims himself...[Redacted] and Carmine 'Tootie' Franzese, the nephew of John Franzese, are the two major shylocks working for Brancato. They loan money to various factory workers and owners of factories in the Greenpoint area and control most of Greenpoint. Montello was unable to furnish the names or the locations of any victims.
...Carmine Franzese and [Redacted] in addition to being shylocks, also operate as bookmakers in the Brancato operation. These two use, as their principle bookmakers, Nick Botta, known as Iron Shoes, from Elmont, Long Island; [Redacted] and [Umberto] Maione. They operate through a social club, located on Merrick Road, across the street from the Big A Diner in Rosedale, Queens. The bookmaking operation pays Brancato $1,000 a week. This club was originally operated by Don Scotto. In addition an individual named [Redacted] (LNU), a W/M, 40’s, stocky build, who was with another Family from Court Street in Brooklyn, also has an interest in the club. They allegedly straighten out all bookmaking activity on Monday nights. Botta and [Redacted] operate a call back bookmaking operation. He described them as one of the largest bookmaking operators in the New York area. Scotto is currently the Manager of the Misty Harbor in Lindenhurst, Long Island.
...About three or four years ago, he knew Joe Brancato was furnishing [John Franzese's family] $500 a week. Normally the money was furnished through Franzese's nephew Carmine Franzese.
...Carmine Franzese and [Redacted] in addition to being shylocks, also operate as bookmakers in the Brancato operation. These two use, as their principle bookmakers, Nick Botta, known as Iron Shoes, from Elmont, Long Island; [Redacted] and [Umberto] Maione. They operate through a social club, located on Merrick Road, across the street from the Big A Diner in Rosedale, Queens. The bookmaking operation pays Brancato $1,000 a week. This club was originally operated by Don Scotto. In addition an individual named [Redacted] (LNU), a W/M, 40’s, stocky build, who was with another Family from Court Street in Brooklyn, also has an interest in the club. They allegedly straighten out all bookmaking activity on Monday nights. Botta and [Redacted] operate a call back bookmaking operation. He described them as one of the largest bookmaking operators in the New York area. Scotto is currently the Manager of the Misty Harbor in Lindenhurst, Long Island.
...About three or four years ago, he knew Joe Brancato was furnishing [John Franzese's family] $500 a week. Normally the money was furnished through Franzese's nephew Carmine Franzese.
"
By mid-May 1975 Carmine served as go between for Brancato and the Family's Gallo faction, handling disputes and delivering messages to and from Colombo Associate Albert 'Blast' Gallo. A source within that group noted: "The informant stated that Franzese is a driver and trusted confidante of Joey Brancato and this would indicate Albert Gallo has aligned himself with the Brancato faction of the Colombo Family..Brancato in his position of leadership in the Family [in] all probability uses Gallo for selected assignments. Informant stated concerning Franzese, he regards Brancato as his 'Godfather' and would do just about anything for Brancato.” Franzese continued this role through 1975.
Around mid-to-late June 1975 wake for Colombo Soldier (and former CI) Gregory Scarpa's mother held in Staten Island. Acting Boss Joseph Brancato, Carmine Franzese and several other crew members attended.
On July 8, 1975 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised that Tutty Franzese is Joe Brancato’s driver and bodyguard, and he considers him to be very ‘two-faced’. Informant stated Tuttie will tell you one thing to your face and go behind your back and say something else. Informant advised Tutty is a real tough guy and is highly trusted by Brancato.”
Around early August 1975 Brancato and Franzese were observed having dinner at Crisci's Restaurant with Colombo Soldier Leonard Dello, Genovese Soldier Pasquale 'Patty Mac' Macchirole, Genovese Associate James 'Jimmy Nap' Napoli, Colombo Associate Vincent Russo and possibly one or more of the Gallos.
Late that month an FBI source identified 'Little Carmine' Franzese and Salvatore DeLauro as loansharks at Spector Freight Services on Grand St in Brooklyn. (DeLauro is believed to be another nephew of Sonny's.)
On September 16, 1975 Unsub, believed to be Colombo Associate John 'Jackie' DeRoss, interviewed by FBI: "...[DeRoss] stated on one occasion about a month ago, he met with Joseph Brancato and Tutti Franzese at a restaurant in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn with [Captain Charles] Panarella." (DeRoss, Panarella's brother-in-law, was inducted into the Colombos around 1977.)
On September 27, 1975 Carmine's daughter married and the reception was held at Queens Terrace Caterers in Woodside.
Attendees included:
By mid-May 1975 Carmine served as go between for Brancato and the Family's Gallo faction, handling disputes and delivering messages to and from Colombo Associate Albert 'Blast' Gallo. A source within that group noted: "The informant stated that Franzese is a driver and trusted confidante of Joey Brancato and this would indicate Albert Gallo has aligned himself with the Brancato faction of the Colombo Family..Brancato in his position of leadership in the Family [in] all probability uses Gallo for selected assignments. Informant stated concerning Franzese, he regards Brancato as his 'Godfather' and would do just about anything for Brancato.” Franzese continued this role through 1975.
Around mid-to-late June 1975 wake for Colombo Soldier (and former CI) Gregory Scarpa's mother held in Staten Island. Acting Boss Joseph Brancato, Carmine Franzese and several other crew members attended.
On July 8, 1975 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised that Tutty Franzese is Joe Brancato’s driver and bodyguard, and he considers him to be very ‘two-faced’. Informant stated Tuttie will tell you one thing to your face and go behind your back and say something else. Informant advised Tutty is a real tough guy and is highly trusted by Brancato.”
Around early August 1975 Brancato and Franzese were observed having dinner at Crisci's Restaurant with Colombo Soldier Leonard Dello, Genovese Soldier Pasquale 'Patty Mac' Macchirole, Genovese Associate James 'Jimmy Nap' Napoli, Colombo Associate Vincent Russo and possibly one or more of the Gallos.
Late that month an FBI source identified 'Little Carmine' Franzese and Salvatore DeLauro as loansharks at Spector Freight Services on Grand St in Brooklyn. (DeLauro is believed to be another nephew of Sonny's.)
On September 16, 1975 Unsub, believed to be Colombo Associate John 'Jackie' DeRoss, interviewed by FBI: "...[DeRoss] stated on one occasion about a month ago, he met with Joseph Brancato and Tutti Franzese at a restaurant in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn with [Captain Charles] Panarella." (DeRoss, Panarella's brother-in-law, was inducted into the Colombos around 1977.)
On September 27, 1975 Carmine's daughter married and the reception was held at Queens Terrace Caterers in Woodside.
Attendees included:
- Thomas DiBella (Colombo Boss)
- Joseph Brancato (Acting Boss)
- Anthony Abbatemarco (Acting Underboss)
- Alphonse Persico (Consigliere)
- James 'Jimmy Brown' Clemenza (Captain)
- Vincent 'Vinny Sicilian' Gugliaro (Captain)
- Vincent 'Jimmy' Muce (Captain)
- Rosario Nastasa (Acting Captain)
- Charles Panarella (Captain)
- Alphonse 'Funzi' D'Ambrosio (Soldier)
- Leonard Dello (Soldier)
- Lawrence 'Larry' Lampasi Jr. (Soldier)
- Anthony LaPonzina (Soldier)
- Ernest 'Ernie Lap' LaPonzina (Soldier)
- Benjamin 'Benny Sidge' LoCicero (Soldier)
- Frank LoCicero (Soldier)
- Andrew Lombardino (Soldier)
- Vincent 'Little Jimmy' Melia (Soldier)
- Rocco 'Rocky' Miraglia (Soldier)
- Modesto Santoro (Soldier)
- James 'Jimmy Skee' Scianna (Soldier)
- Joseph Vitacco (Soldier)
- Salvatore Albanese (Associate)
- Michael Bolino (Associate)
- Dominic Cataldo (Associate)
- Anthony Colombo (Associate)
- Joseph Colombo Jr. (Associate)
- Frank 'Frankie the Beast' Falanga (Associate)
- Salvatore Fusco (Associate)
- Albert Gallo (Associate)
- Joseph 'Joe Notch' Iannaci (Associate)
- Frank 'Punchy' Illiano (Associate)
- Gennaro 'Jerry Lang' Langella (Associate)
- John Pate (Associate)
- Andrew Russo (Associate)
- Ralph Scopo (Associate)
- Joseph Brancato (Acting Boss)
- Anthony Abbatemarco (Acting Underboss)
- Alphonse Persico (Consigliere)
- James 'Jimmy Brown' Clemenza (Captain)
- Vincent 'Vinny Sicilian' Gugliaro (Captain)
- Vincent 'Jimmy' Muce (Captain)
- Rosario Nastasa (Acting Captain)
- Charles Panarella (Captain)
- Alphonse 'Funzi' D'Ambrosio (Soldier)
- Leonard Dello (Soldier)
- Lawrence 'Larry' Lampasi Jr. (Soldier)
- Anthony LaPonzina (Soldier)
- Ernest 'Ernie Lap' LaPonzina (Soldier)
- Benjamin 'Benny Sidge' LoCicero (Soldier)
- Frank LoCicero (Soldier)
- Andrew Lombardino (Soldier)
- Vincent 'Little Jimmy' Melia (Soldier)
- Rocco 'Rocky' Miraglia (Soldier)
- Modesto Santoro (Soldier)
- James 'Jimmy Skee' Scianna (Soldier)
- Joseph Vitacco (Soldier)
- Salvatore Albanese (Associate)
- Michael Bolino (Associate)
- Dominic Cataldo (Associate)
- Anthony Colombo (Associate)
- Joseph Colombo Jr. (Associate)
- Frank 'Frankie the Beast' Falanga (Associate)
- Salvatore Fusco (Associate)
- Albert Gallo (Associate)
- Joseph 'Joe Notch' Iannaci (Associate)
- Frank 'Punchy' Illiano (Associate)
- Gennaro 'Jerry Lang' Langella (Associate)
- John Pate (Associate)
- Andrew Russo (Associate)
- Ralph Scopo (Associate)
The following day a reception for Soldier Leonard Dello's daughter was held at the same place. Most of the same individuals, including Brancato and Franzese, attended.
On October 4, 1975 a reception for Soldier Rocco Miraglia's daughter was held at Shalimar Caterers in New Dorp, Staten Island. Brancato, Franzese and most of those named above were in attendance.
That month the FBI's Gallo crew CI gave an update: "...Al Gallo continues to run his operation down on President Street [and] Franzese is [there] to keep Brancato's interests intact and report to Brancato on any of Gallo's activities. Informant advised he feels Joseph Brancato regards Gallo quite highly, but he does not completely trust him.”
The following day: "Gallo is usually [redacted] by Carmine 'Turi' Franzese and they generally will talk, drink coffee and anisette for a couple of hours at a time. The informant advised he knows Al Gallo is aware of the reason Franzese visits [redacted] for Joey Brancato, but apparently [redacted]."
October 16: "[Gallo] and Franzese appeared to be very tight, but it is merely Joey Brancato’s subtle way to keep an eye on the Gallo crew." (Further violence surrounding the Gallos subsequently led to Albert being released and inducted into the Genovese Family.)
That same day a source advised the FBI that 'Little Carmine' Franzese and Salvatore DeLauro continued to operated at Spector Freight: "Both individuals make shylock loans and, if necessary, use force to collect the loans. On occasion, a relative of Franzese known as 'Big Tuttie' has threatened employees of Spector to pay their debts."
On October 20, 1975 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised that Joe Brancato still gets around Brooklyn regularly and visits with many of the Colombo Family. Informant stated Brancato is accompanied by his driver and friend Tutti Franzese, whom Brancato considers his protégé and bodyguard. Informant advised Brancato continues to be very discreet in his actions and doubts very much if he gets directly involved in any type of street crime.”
In early November 1975 a relative of Soldier Alphonse D'Ambrosio married with the reception held at Manor East in Massapequa, Long Island. Brancato, Franzese and many others attended.
By December 1975 Brancato was longer the Acting Boss and resumed his role as official Captain.
In early 1976 the New York Families opened the books and inductions resumed. Each Family was initially allowed ten new members. On February 5 Franzese was made as part of this initial group under Brancato's sponsorship.
The first available informant report confirming the inductions took place came five days later on February 10.
On March 17, 1976 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Carmine 'Tuttie' Franzese was sponsored for membership in the Colombo LCN Family by Joseph Brancato, and Franzese was 'made' over the objections of his uncle, John 'Sonny' Franzese. The informant did not know the reason for John Franzese's objections."
On March 18, 1976 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised ‘books’ are open again in the Mafia and four new ‘buttons’ were made last week. Tuttie Franzese was made and is with his uncle Sonny Franzese and Jo Jo Brancato’s crew.”
On March 24, 1976 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised on or about 3/2/76, ten individuals were sponsored by Carmine ‘Lilo’ Galante to be made button guys in the LCN. Informant stated this was the first time since 1957 the books in NY had been opened to anyone. Informant stated Lilo sponsored Tutti Franzese of the Colombo Crime Family with the approval of Joseph Brancato...Informant stated the appointment of Franzese was probably done as a favor to his uncle, John Franzese who is currently in jail. This move has created a great deal of displeasure with people on the street, some of whom felt they were more deserving than Franzese. Informant estimated as a result of Franzese’s ‘made’ position he will head up to 100 men.”
On March 25, 1976 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised Carmine Franzese is a shylock and hijacker who is a big earner. [Redacted] is with Franzese in his shylocking business, and [Redacted] and Franzese meet regularly on Wednesday's at Crisci's Restaurant."
On March 26, 1976 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised he heard Colombo Family wiseguys were told to attend a 25th anniversary party for Tutti Franzese to be held at the Queens Terrace on Sunday, 3/28/1976, starting about 6:00 PM to 7:00 PM. Informant advised party is a tribute to Franzese and big turnout is expected because he is backed by Joseph Brancato. Informant heard Tutti Franzese has ‘taken over’ the financial control of the Queens Terrace.”
On April 20, 1976 FBI New York advised Headquarters: "As the Bureau is aware, on 2/5/1976, Carmine Franzese was 'made' by the Colombo LCN Family. To protect sources of the New York Office, no active investigation is being conducted at this time concerning Franzese, now that he is a 'made guy'. It is anticipated after additional information is received from additional sources concerning the new status of Franzese, investigation on Franzese will be intensified."
On May 14, 1976 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised Joseph Brancato had his number one man Tutti Franzese made recently through the suggestion of Tutti’s uncle John Franzese."
Later that month Franzese participated in his first known murder.
 |
| J. Pastore (NYDN) |
Colombo Associate and Brancato crew member Joseph 'Dodo' Pastore had been marked for death with the authorization of Family Boss Thomas DiBella.
Franzese and others were unable to set Pastore up and sought assistance from the Bonanno Family.
At the time Pastore was involved in business with Bonanno Associate Joseph Massino.
Franzese and others were unable to set Pastore up and sought assistance from the Bonanno Family.
At the time Pastore was involved in business with Bonanno Associate Joseph Massino.
 |
| J. Massino (L), Unsub and N. Marangello (1977) |
Massino later testified: "I was to go downtown. At that point I was an associate and I was answering to underboss in the Bonanno Family by the name of Nicky Glasses [Marangello]. He says to me, "[Brancato] just came here the other day with Tuttie, and they want a favor. They're having a hard time getting this guy and we all need allies. They want to murder him. Can you set him up? I said, "Well, he comes by my deli every Saturday' [and] I agreed to do it."
Around the night of May 22 Brancato, Franzese and Pastore were observed inside Crisci's Restaurant in Williamsburg.
Soon after Pastore visited Massino at his deli and, upon entering an upstairs apartment, was shot to death by a waiting Franzese. Colombo Soldier Joseph Vitacco may have also been present.
Around the night of May 22 Brancato, Franzese and Pastore were observed inside Crisci's Restaurant in Williamsburg.
Soon after Pastore visited Massino at his deli and, upon entering an upstairs apartment, was shot to death by a waiting Franzese. Colombo Soldier Joseph Vitacco may have also been present.
 |
| J. Vitacco (L) and S. Vitale |
Massino contacted his brother-in-law Salvatore Vitale and ordered him to clean up the crime scene.
At 3:10 AM on May 23 Pastore's vehicle, his wallet on the front seat, was found abandoned in Queens.
On June 1 his decomposing remains, wrapped in a sheet, were discovered next to a dumpster in the private lot of Alfred Blever Paper Company at 57-77 57th St in Maspeth. Joseph Massino accompanied Pastore's half-brother Richard Dorme to identify the body.
On June 8, 1976 the NYPD advised FBI: "[Detective] advised he is investigating the homicide of Joseph Pastore...[NYPD] determined Pastore had numerous organized crime connections and subsequent to Pastore’s disappearance on 5/23/1976, and prior to the finding of his body on 6/1/1976, Carmine Franzese has taken over the gambling and loanshark operation controlled by Pastore at the Miami Bar, Brooklyn.” (The Miami Bar was located on Richardson St in Williamsburg.)
On June 11, 1976 FBI CI passed along information he had heard that two months prior to Pastore's murder, his half-brother Richard Dorme was kidnapped by Franzese and Colombo Soldiers Anthony Augello and Modesto Santoro. Pastore paid $150,000 to have Dorme released and, after finding out who was responsible, went to Genovese Member Pasquale Macchirole and let it be known he intended to get his money back and 'fix' Franzese and the others.
The informant reported that Franzese met with Macchirole and decided Pastore would have to die for the threat. Macchirole agreed but wanted to leave New York 'until everything calmed down'. The informant said Pastore was found with his fingernails ripped out and 'every bone in his body broke'. Franzese had taken over Pastore's gambling business and loanshark customers and the informant wasn't sure if Dorme, who now worked for Franzese, knew who had actually kidnapped him. (Dorme was himself found shot to death early the following year.)
On June 15, 1976 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised he learned Carmine ‘Tuttie’ Franzese and Little Jo Jo (LNU) (Vitacco) were responsible for the recent slaying of Dodo Pastore and probably did the ‘hit’ themselves. This was a torture killing in that the victim’s body was found in a dump with his fingernails missing and probably pulled out, and badly beaten. The informant said narcotics was rumored as the probable [reason].”
On August 4, 1976 FBI NYO reported: “Carmine Salvatore Franzese is a newly made member of the Colombo LCN Family [redacted]. Franzese is the former driver and bodyguard for Joseph Brancato and since becoming a ‘made guy’ in the LCN, has a large crew working under him involved in smuggling and loansharking. Recent information received by the NYO indicates that Franzese is extremely vicious when collecting loanshark payments.”
On August 11, 1976 Unspecified Male interviewed by FBI: “[UM] stated he is good friends with Joseph Brancato as they grew up together, and he had dinner with Brancato approximately 2 weeks ago. [UM] stated he is also acquainted with Carmine Franzese aka Tuttie, [redacted]. [UM] stated he considers Brancato a fine gentleman and a good friend, however he did not think too highly of Tuttie Franzese. [UM] stated he considers Franzese an unrefined individual. [UM] stated he has never borrowed any money from Brancato or Franzese and he would definitely not borrow from Franzese if he needed it. He stated he believed Brancato would lend him any amount of money if Brancato had it and not charge him any interest on it.”
By September 1976 Brancato and Franzese were subjects in an FBI investigation of the Pastore murder.
On December 2, 1976 FBI NY compiled an update on the Colombo Family's structure. The chart identified Joseph Brancato as a Captain and noted his crew members as including Carmine Franzese.
By that time Brancato had thrown in with a faction of the Colombo Family seeking to depose Boss Thomas DiBella.
The Commission was called in to resolve the dispute and sided with DiBella, leading to Brancato and other dissidents being demoted and the Family undergoing a large scale reorganization.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 67 identified Colombo Family members.
At 3:10 AM on May 23 Pastore's vehicle, his wallet on the front seat, was found abandoned in Queens.
On June 1 his decomposing remains, wrapped in a sheet, were discovered next to a dumpster in the private lot of Alfred Blever Paper Company at 57-77 57th St in Maspeth. Joseph Massino accompanied Pastore's half-brother Richard Dorme to identify the body.
On June 8, 1976 the NYPD advised FBI: "[Detective] advised he is investigating the homicide of Joseph Pastore...[NYPD] determined Pastore had numerous organized crime connections and subsequent to Pastore’s disappearance on 5/23/1976, and prior to the finding of his body on 6/1/1976, Carmine Franzese has taken over the gambling and loanshark operation controlled by Pastore at the Miami Bar, Brooklyn.” (The Miami Bar was located on Richardson St in Williamsburg.)
On June 11, 1976 FBI CI passed along information he had heard that two months prior to Pastore's murder, his half-brother Richard Dorme was kidnapped by Franzese and Colombo Soldiers Anthony Augello and Modesto Santoro. Pastore paid $150,000 to have Dorme released and, after finding out who was responsible, went to Genovese Member Pasquale Macchirole and let it be known he intended to get his money back and 'fix' Franzese and the others.
The informant reported that Franzese met with Macchirole and decided Pastore would have to die for the threat. Macchirole agreed but wanted to leave New York 'until everything calmed down'. The informant said Pastore was found with his fingernails ripped out and 'every bone in his body broke'. Franzese had taken over Pastore's gambling business and loanshark customers and the informant wasn't sure if Dorme, who now worked for Franzese, knew who had actually kidnapped him. (Dorme was himself found shot to death early the following year.)
On June 15, 1976 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised he learned Carmine ‘Tuttie’ Franzese and Little Jo Jo (LNU) (Vitacco) were responsible for the recent slaying of Dodo Pastore and probably did the ‘hit’ themselves. This was a torture killing in that the victim’s body was found in a dump with his fingernails missing and probably pulled out, and badly beaten. The informant said narcotics was rumored as the probable [reason].”
On August 4, 1976 FBI NYO reported: “Carmine Salvatore Franzese is a newly made member of the Colombo LCN Family [redacted]. Franzese is the former driver and bodyguard for Joseph Brancato and since becoming a ‘made guy’ in the LCN, has a large crew working under him involved in smuggling and loansharking. Recent information received by the NYO indicates that Franzese is extremely vicious when collecting loanshark payments.”
On August 11, 1976 Unspecified Male interviewed by FBI: “[UM] stated he is good friends with Joseph Brancato as they grew up together, and he had dinner with Brancato approximately 2 weeks ago. [UM] stated he is also acquainted with Carmine Franzese aka Tuttie, [redacted]. [UM] stated he considers Brancato a fine gentleman and a good friend, however he did not think too highly of Tuttie Franzese. [UM] stated he considers Franzese an unrefined individual. [UM] stated he has never borrowed any money from Brancato or Franzese and he would definitely not borrow from Franzese if he needed it. He stated he believed Brancato would lend him any amount of money if Brancato had it and not charge him any interest on it.”
By September 1976 Brancato and Franzese were subjects in an FBI investigation of the Pastore murder.
On December 2, 1976 FBI NY compiled an update on the Colombo Family's structure. The chart identified Joseph Brancato as a Captain and noted his crew members as including Carmine Franzese.
By that time Brancato had thrown in with a faction of the Colombo Family seeking to depose Boss Thomas DiBella.
The Commission was called in to resolve the dispute and sided with DiBella, leading to Brancato and other dissidents being demoted and the Family undergoing a large scale reorganization.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 67 identified Colombo Family members.
 |
| L to R: J. Massino, C. Franzese, A. Mirra Toyland Social Club (2/18/77) |
On February 18, 1977 FBI surveillance conducted on Toyland Social Club located at 94 Hester St in Lower Manhattan. The club was operated by Bonanno Underboss Nicholas Marangello and served as one of that Family's primary meeting places in the borough. Those observed included Franzese, Joseph Massino and Bonanno Soldier Anthony Mirra.
On March 1, 1977 Franzese and Massino were again surveilled together at Toyland.
By March 1977 Franzese reported to Captain Andrew Russo.
Made members of Russo's crew included Leonard Dello, Philip 'Fat Foongie' Gambino, Joseph 'Joe Black' Gorgone, Anthony 'Tony Skee' Scianna and Joseph Vitacco. (Gambino and Gorgone were made in the same ceremony as Franzese.)
On March 1, 1977 Franzese and Massino were again surveilled together at Toyland.
By March 1977 Franzese reported to Captain Andrew Russo.
Made members of Russo's crew included Leonard Dello, Philip 'Fat Foongie' Gambino, Joseph 'Joe Black' Gorgone, Anthony 'Tony Skee' Scianna and Joseph Vitacco. (Gambino and Gorgone were made in the same ceremony as Franzese.)
 |
| J. Massino (L) and C. Franzese Toyland Social Club (4/22/77) |
On April 22, 1977 Franzese and Massino were surveilled at Toyland.
 |
| L to R: FNU DiStefano, N. Marangello, C. Franzese, A. Embarrato, J. Massino Toyland Social Club (8/27/77) |
On August 27, 1977 Agents observed Franzese, Massino, Bonanno Underboss Nicholas Marangello, Bonanno Soldier Alfred 'Al Walker' Embarrato and FNU DiStefano outside Toyland. (FNU DiStefano may be Captain Nicholas 'Nick the Battler' DiStefano. Joseph Massino had by then been inducted into the Bonanno Family. Within a couple of years he was appointed a Captain, then Underboss and ultimately took over the Family in 1991.)
By September 1977 Joseph Brancato had joined his former crew members Carmine Franzese and Joseph Vitacco in reporting to Captain Andrew Russo.
By November 1977 made members of the Russo crew included John Bolino, Joseph Brancato, Leonard Dello, Carmine Franzese, Philip Gambino, Joseph Gorgone, Joseph Peraino, Anthony Scianna and Joseph Vitacco.
By the following month Brancato was transferred to Captain Gennaro Langella.
On October 15, 1978 Newsday published "Top 25 Mobsters in Queens". An entry for Carmine Franzese noted: "Family soldier, relative of John Franzese. Activities include gambling and loansharking. Operates in Brooklyn and frequents bars and social clubs there."
In February 1979 Carmine's uncle Sonny Franzese was paroled from Federal prison and soon regained his Captain rank.
In June 1979 included in the FBI's list of 94 identified Colombo Family members.
An FBI chart from the same month noted Carmine continued reporting to Andrew Russo.
On March 3, 1980 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised Jo Jo Vitacco, Colombo LCN Family Member, recently passed away on 2/29/1980...Source stated he anticipates Joseph Brancato, Tutti Franzese, and [Redacted] will be in attendance at the wake. Source stated at the time of his death, Vitacco [redacted]. Source stated he thought [Redacted] may have a problem with Franzese and Brancato inasmuch as he had a large outstanding loan to Jo Jo Vitacco...Source does not think Brancato and Franzese will allow [Redacted] any leeway in paying off this loan.”
By Summer 1980 Carmine and his uncle Sonny Franzese were subjects of an FBI RICO investigation.
As of October 1980 Carmine was taken out of Andrew Russo's crew and reported to his uncle.
Made members of Sonny Franzese's crew included Carmine Franzese, Anthony 'Butch' Maltese and Rocco Miraglia.
Early that month the FBI interviewed Carmine, who presented himself as a self-employed canteen truck driver selling coffee in Long Island City.
On October 6, 1980 included in DEA list of 86 identified Colombo Family members.
On October 17, 1980 included in the FBI's list of 90 identified Colombo Family members.
Around Spring 1981 Franzese and Colombo Associate Vinny LNU met with Bonanno Captain Joseph Massino and alerted them that members of a rival faction in that Family were stockpiling weapons. This led to Massino and others getting permission from other New York Family Bosses to strike first. Three leaders of the rival faction were ambushed and shot to death on May 5.
In July 1981 an informant reported that Franzese and other Colombo members were meeting at Nick's Coffee Shop in Greenpoint.
By September 1977 Joseph Brancato had joined his former crew members Carmine Franzese and Joseph Vitacco in reporting to Captain Andrew Russo.
By November 1977 made members of the Russo crew included John Bolino, Joseph Brancato, Leonard Dello, Carmine Franzese, Philip Gambino, Joseph Gorgone, Joseph Peraino, Anthony Scianna and Joseph Vitacco.
By the following month Brancato was transferred to Captain Gennaro Langella.
On October 15, 1978 Newsday published "Top 25 Mobsters in Queens". An entry for Carmine Franzese noted: "Family soldier, relative of John Franzese. Activities include gambling and loansharking. Operates in Brooklyn and frequents bars and social clubs there."
In February 1979 Carmine's uncle Sonny Franzese was paroled from Federal prison and soon regained his Captain rank.
In June 1979 included in the FBI's list of 94 identified Colombo Family members.
An FBI chart from the same month noted Carmine continued reporting to Andrew Russo.
On March 3, 1980 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised Jo Jo Vitacco, Colombo LCN Family Member, recently passed away on 2/29/1980...Source stated he anticipates Joseph Brancato, Tutti Franzese, and [Redacted] will be in attendance at the wake. Source stated at the time of his death, Vitacco [redacted]. Source stated he thought [Redacted] may have a problem with Franzese and Brancato inasmuch as he had a large outstanding loan to Jo Jo Vitacco...Source does not think Brancato and Franzese will allow [Redacted] any leeway in paying off this loan.”
By Summer 1980 Carmine and his uncle Sonny Franzese were subjects of an FBI RICO investigation.
As of October 1980 Carmine was taken out of Andrew Russo's crew and reported to his uncle.
Made members of Sonny Franzese's crew included Carmine Franzese, Anthony 'Butch' Maltese and Rocco Miraglia.
Early that month the FBI interviewed Carmine, who presented himself as a self-employed canteen truck driver selling coffee in Long Island City.
On October 6, 1980 included in DEA list of 86 identified Colombo Family members.
On October 17, 1980 included in the FBI's list of 90 identified Colombo Family members.
Around Spring 1981 Franzese and Colombo Associate Vinny LNU met with Bonanno Captain Joseph Massino and alerted them that members of a rival faction in that Family were stockpiling weapons. This led to Massino and others getting permission from other New York Family Bosses to strike first. Three leaders of the rival faction were ambushed and shot to death on May 5.
In July 1981 an informant reported that Franzese and other Colombo members were meeting at Nick's Coffee Shop in Greenpoint.
 |
| C. Franzese at Cataldo Reception (1981) |
In August 1981 the wedding reception for a relative of Colombo Soldier Dominic 'Little Dom' Cataldo was held at La Mer Caterers in Midwood, Brooklyn. Attendees included Colombo Captain Benedetto 'Benny' Aloi, Gambino Acting Captain John Gotti, Bonanno Captain Joseph Massino, Colombo Soldiers Joseph Brancato, Carmine Franzese and Vito Guzzo and Gambino Soldier Angelo Ruggiero.
 |
| Franzese at Vitale Communion (c. 1982) |
Around 1982 Franzese attended the communion party for a son of Bonanno Associate Salvatore Vitale. Years prior Vitale had cleaned up the apartment where Pastore was shot dead by Franzese. Party attendees included Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associates Joseph DeSimone, Duane 'Goldie' Leisenheimer, Marinello 'Marty' Rastelli and James 'Big Lou' Tartaglione.
In March of the same year Vitale's brother-in-law Joseph Massino, now a Bonanno Captain, went on the lam to avoid a Federal racketeering indictment. During his time as a fugitive Massino's visitors included Carmine Franzese and Colombo Soldier Patsy 'Junior' Palermo.
In June 1983 included in Senate Chart of Colombo Family membership.
On January 29, 1984 Franzese and Bonanno Associate Salvatore Vitale were surveilled by the FBI at El Morocco Restaurant in Midtown Manhattan. About an hour later Bonanno Acting Captain Anthony Spero was observed.
On August 7, 1984 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking located at 58-23 58th Rd in Maspeth. Company owned by Massino, Vitale and Bonanno Associate Carmen Peluso. Those observed included Bonanno Acting Captains Alfred Embarrato, Frank Lino and Anthony Spero, Bonanno Soldiers Frank Coppa, Pasquale 'Patty Boxcars' Cosoleto and James 'Jimmy' Galante, Possible Bonanno Member Louis Restivo, Possible Gambino Member Joseph Siciliano and Bonanno Associates Carmen Peluso, Marinello Rastelli and Salvatore Vitale. Additional observations included vehicles registered to Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associate Anthony 'Tony Green' Urso.
On May 7, 1986 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa reported: “[Scarpa] advised [Redacted] for Tuttie Franzese, and is involved in a gambling operation...[Scarpa] noted Franzese spends much of his time in Florida, but comes to New York about once a month to check on his gambling and loansharking.”
In March of the same year Vitale's brother-in-law Joseph Massino, now a Bonanno Captain, went on the lam to avoid a Federal racketeering indictment. During his time as a fugitive Massino's visitors included Carmine Franzese and Colombo Soldier Patsy 'Junior' Palermo.
In June 1983 included in Senate Chart of Colombo Family membership.
On January 29, 1984 Franzese and Bonanno Associate Salvatore Vitale were surveilled by the FBI at El Morocco Restaurant in Midtown Manhattan. About an hour later Bonanno Acting Captain Anthony Spero was observed.
On August 7, 1984 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking located at 58-23 58th Rd in Maspeth. Company owned by Massino, Vitale and Bonanno Associate Carmen Peluso. Those observed included Bonanno Acting Captains Alfred Embarrato, Frank Lino and Anthony Spero, Bonanno Soldiers Frank Coppa, Pasquale 'Patty Boxcars' Cosoleto and James 'Jimmy' Galante, Possible Bonanno Member Louis Restivo, Possible Gambino Member Joseph Siciliano and Bonanno Associates Carmen Peluso, Marinello Rastelli and Salvatore Vitale. Additional observations included vehicles registered to Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associate Anthony 'Tony Green' Urso.
On May 7, 1986 FBI CI Gregory Scarpa reported: “[Scarpa] advised [Redacted] for Tuttie Franzese, and is involved in a gambling operation...[Scarpa] noted Franzese spends much of his time in Florida, but comes to New York about once a month to check on his gambling and loansharking.”
 |
| R. Hubert |
On June 3, 1986 CI Scarpa reported: “[Scarpa] advised [Richard 'Red'] Hubert continues to handle loansharking for Colombo member Tuttie Franzese, and illegal gambling...[Scarpa] again noted Franzese comes to New York about one week per month to check on his gambling and loansharking, and the rest of the time is spent in Florida.”
On July 18, 1986 CI Scarpa passed along three phone numbers used by the Franzese operation.
By 1987 resided in North Tarrytown, New York. Listed occupation as construction goods salesman.
On October 26, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed included Bonanno Captain James Tartaglione, Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associate Michael 'Mickey Bats' Cardello.
On November 10, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed included Bonanno Captain Louis Restivo, Bonanno Captain Salvatore Vitale, Bonanno Soldier Frank Coppa, Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese, Bonanno Associate Vito Grimaldi, Genovese (Colombo?) Associate Richard Hubert and Bonanno Associate Carmen Peluso.
On November 17, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed were Bonanno Captain Louis Restivo, Captain James Tartaglione and Bonanno Soldiers Vincent Asaro, Gasper 'Skin' Cammarata and John 'Porky' Zancocchio. Others in attendance included Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associates Sandro Aiosa, Michael Cardello, Carmen Peluso and Pietro 'Pete' Rosa. Additional observations included vehicle registered to Possible Bonanno Member Louis Mele. (Pietro Rosa may have been made by then. As late as 1992 an informant stated Louis Mele was 'not believed to be made'.)
In 1988 included in Senate Chart of Colombo Family membership.
On September 13-14, 1989 attended the wake for Colombo Consigliere Alphonse Persico held at Scarpaci Funeral Home in Bensonhurst. Attendees in addition to Franzese included multiple members of at least four of the New York Families. (No Genovese names are noted in what's available.)
Around this time Lenny LNU was paying protection money to Colombo Associate John Franzese Jr., Carmine's cousin and a son of the again imprisoned Sonny Franzese. Lenny, who was partners in a local print shop, kicked up $1,000 to $1,500 for about three weeks before the arrangement was shut down by Consigliere Benedetto Aloi. Called to a meeting with Aloi, Franzese Jr. spoke with his father beforehand. Franzese Jr. later testified: "My father told me [the Colombo leadership] hadn't already made up their mind to kill me, then if I went to the appointment then I would be okay. But if they were looking to see if I would come to the appointment or not, and I didn't show up, then [I] would make their mind up for them by not going...[When] I walked in there, nobody was in the club. This one guy named Schwartzy (Vincent Cascio), who was also a good fellow, and he just kept telling me to wait, that someone was going to take me to see Benny Aloi. For about an hour and a half, it was just me and [Cascio]. And then out of nowhere, my cousin, Tutti Franzese, came running into the place screaming and yelling at me to get the hell out of there. That nobody can help me, not even my father. Don't come around, even to him. There's nothing anyone can do for me [meaning they weren't sure] my father would accept them going with the Vic Orena faction. And that they had decided that anyone that wasn't with Vic Orena, that they would look to kill or hurt." (The conflict between the Orena and Persico factions subsequently erupted into open warfare.)
Carmine Franzese died December 29, 1990 at his residence in North Tarrytown.
CI Greg Scarpa advised Agents of the death in late March 1991.
Carmine's name was included in the deceased column of a Colombo Family induction list passed to the other Families in late 2003.
On July 18, 1986 CI Scarpa passed along three phone numbers used by the Franzese operation.
By 1987 resided in North Tarrytown, New York. Listed occupation as construction goods salesman.
On October 26, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed included Bonanno Captain James Tartaglione, Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associate Michael 'Mickey Bats' Cardello.
On November 10, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed included Bonanno Captain Louis Restivo, Bonanno Captain Salvatore Vitale, Bonanno Soldier Frank Coppa, Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese, Bonanno Associate Vito Grimaldi, Genovese (Colombo?) Associate Richard Hubert and Bonanno Associate Carmen Peluso.
On November 17, 1987 FBI surveillance conducted on MVP Trucking. Those observed were Bonanno Captain Louis Restivo, Captain James Tartaglione and Bonanno Soldiers Vincent Asaro, Gasper 'Skin' Cammarata and John 'Porky' Zancocchio. Others in attendance included Colombo Soldier Carmine Franzese and Bonanno Associates Sandro Aiosa, Michael Cardello, Carmen Peluso and Pietro 'Pete' Rosa. Additional observations included vehicle registered to Possible Bonanno Member Louis Mele. (Pietro Rosa may have been made by then. As late as 1992 an informant stated Louis Mele was 'not believed to be made'.)
In 1988 included in Senate Chart of Colombo Family membership.
On September 13-14, 1989 attended the wake for Colombo Consigliere Alphonse Persico held at Scarpaci Funeral Home in Bensonhurst. Attendees in addition to Franzese included multiple members of at least four of the New York Families. (No Genovese names are noted in what's available.)
Around this time Lenny LNU was paying protection money to Colombo Associate John Franzese Jr., Carmine's cousin and a son of the again imprisoned Sonny Franzese. Lenny, who was partners in a local print shop, kicked up $1,000 to $1,500 for about three weeks before the arrangement was shut down by Consigliere Benedetto Aloi. Called to a meeting with Aloi, Franzese Jr. spoke with his father beforehand. Franzese Jr. later testified: "My father told me [the Colombo leadership] hadn't already made up their mind to kill me, then if I went to the appointment then I would be okay. But if they were looking to see if I would come to the appointment or not, and I didn't show up, then [I] would make their mind up for them by not going...[When] I walked in there, nobody was in the club. This one guy named Schwartzy (Vincent Cascio), who was also a good fellow, and he just kept telling me to wait, that someone was going to take me to see Benny Aloi. For about an hour and a half, it was just me and [Cascio]. And then out of nowhere, my cousin, Tutti Franzese, came running into the place screaming and yelling at me to get the hell out of there. That nobody can help me, not even my father. Don't come around, even to him. There's nothing anyone can do for me [meaning they weren't sure] my father would accept them going with the Vic Orena faction. And that they had decided that anyone that wasn't with Vic Orena, that they would look to kill or hurt." (The conflict between the Orena and Persico factions subsequently erupted into open warfare.)
Carmine Franzese died December 29, 1990 at his residence in North Tarrytown.
CI Greg Scarpa advised Agents of the death in late March 1991.
Carmine's name was included in the deceased column of a Colombo Family induction list passed to the other Families in late 2003.
