 |
| 1960s |
Vincent 'Jimmy' Sarullo was a made member of the Gambino Family's Traina crew.
He was active in Staten Island as both a club / trucking company owner and as a heavy participant in local gambling and loansharking operations.
Born March 29, 1917 in Manhattan to Biaggio (Barber; 21y) and Theresa Bellina (19y). Father from Ribera comune of Agrigento, Sicily. Mother from Province of Palermo.
At the time of Vincent's birth the Sarullos were residing at 440 East 13th St in Manhattan's East Village neighborhood.
Around 1920 they moved to South Beach, Staten Island.
On March 25 of that year Dr. Vincenzo Campisi (32y) and Lorenzo Sarullo (28y) were found stabbed to death at 496 Lorimer St in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Both resided in Elizabeth, New Jersey at the time and the press speculated the murders were an outgrowth of gang violence in Newark. Sarullo's body was identified by his younger brother Vincenzo. Four years later Vincenzo was found at the city dump with his throat cut. (It's possible these Sarullos were relatives of Jimmy Sarullo. The murder victims' parents are listed as Francesco and Ninfa Gagliano.)
By 1931 Jimmy Sarullo and family were residing at 18 Balfour St in South Beach.
From 1937 to about 1941 he worked on the assembly line of Ford Motor Company in Edgewater, New Jersey. Vincent's father was foreman at the Knickerbocker Construction Company in Manhattan.
On April 27, 1940 married Genevieve Sorrentino (21y) in Staten Island. Bride's family from Cava de' Tirreni comune of Salerno, Campania.
He was active in Staten Island as both a club / trucking company owner and as a heavy participant in local gambling and loansharking operations.
Born March 29, 1917 in Manhattan to Biaggio (Barber; 21y) and Theresa Bellina (19y). Father from Ribera comune of Agrigento, Sicily. Mother from Province of Palermo.
At the time of Vincent's birth the Sarullos were residing at 440 East 13th St in Manhattan's East Village neighborhood.
Around 1920 they moved to South Beach, Staten Island.
On March 25 of that year Dr. Vincenzo Campisi (32y) and Lorenzo Sarullo (28y) were found stabbed to death at 496 Lorimer St in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Both resided in Elizabeth, New Jersey at the time and the press speculated the murders were an outgrowth of gang violence in Newark. Sarullo's body was identified by his younger brother Vincenzo. Four years later Vincenzo was found at the city dump with his throat cut. (It's possible these Sarullos were relatives of Jimmy Sarullo. The murder victims' parents are listed as Francesco and Ninfa Gagliano.)
By 1931 Jimmy Sarullo and family were residing at 18 Balfour St in South Beach.
From 1937 to about 1941 he worked on the assembly line of Ford Motor Company in Edgewater, New Jersey. Vincent's father was foreman at the Knickerbocker Construction Company in Manhattan.
On April 27, 1940 married Genevieve Sorrentino (21y) in Staten Island. Bride's family from Cava de' Tirreni comune of Salerno, Campania.
 |
| V. Sarullo (1940s) |
Around 1941 started employment as reel shop supervisor with General Cable Company in Bayonne, New Jersey. He left around 1946 and spent several years as a longshoreman with various stevedoring companies on the Manhattan piers.
In 1953 opened Club Trio located at 227 Sand Lane, about a block away from the family residence in South Beach.
By 1958 Sarullo was a made member of the Gambino Family and reported to Joseph Traina.
In 1953 opened Club Trio located at 227 Sand Lane, about a block away from the family residence in South Beach.
By 1958 Sarullo was a made member of the Gambino Family and reported to Joseph Traina.
 |
| J. Traina FBN Mafia Book |
Made members under Traina included Vincent 'Jimmy' Amato, Louis 'Fat Louie' D'Agostino (Traina's step-brother), Pietro 'Little Pete Lombardo' Giallombardo, Joseph Giardina and his sons Joseph Jr., Louis 'Red' and Salvatore 'Teddy' Giardina, Philip LiCastri, Vincent LiCastri (Philip's son), Angelo Mannino, Samuel Mannino (Angelo's son), Paul 'Whitey' SanFilippo, Vincent 'Jimmy' Sarullo, Salvatore 'Sam' Tirone and Mario 'Red' Traina (Joseph's son).
Probable crew members included Charles LiCastri (another of Philip's sons) and Paul SanFilippo's father Joseph.
All of the known Traina crew members from the time period were Sicilian. The majority traced their origins to Palermo, either the city itself (Amato) or neighboring communes Marineo (the LiCastris), Torretta (the Manninos) or, like Traina, Belmonte Mezzagno (Giallombardo).
Non-Palermitani who reported to Traina included the Giardinas from Mussomeli in Caltanissetta, the SanFilippos from Sciacca and Vincent Sarullo, as yet the only known local member from Ribera, Agrigento not with the DeCavalcantes.
In March 1961 Sarullo began operating Benigno and Sarullo Inc., a trucking company at 179 Jefferson Ave in Midland Beach, SI.
Probable crew members included Charles LiCastri (another of Philip's sons) and Paul SanFilippo's father Joseph.
All of the known Traina crew members from the time period were Sicilian. The majority traced their origins to Palermo, either the city itself (Amato) or neighboring communes Marineo (the LiCastris), Torretta (the Manninos) or, like Traina, Belmonte Mezzagno (Giallombardo).
Non-Palermitani who reported to Traina included the Giardinas from Mussomeli in Caltanissetta, the SanFilippos from Sciacca and Vincent Sarullo, as yet the only known local member from Ribera, Agrigento not with the DeCavalcantes.
In March 1961 Sarullo began operating Benigno and Sarullo Inc., a trucking company at 179 Jefferson Ave in Midland Beach, SI.
 |
| P. LiCastri |
He first came to the attention of the FBI in March 1963. CI Gregory Scarpa, a Colombo Soldier, identified the owners of both the LiCastri Bakery and the Trio Club in Staten Island as Gambino members. In summarizing Scarpa's information, the FBI added that 'various sources' identified Sarullo as an active participant in the local numbers business. (LiCastri Bakery was owned by Philip LiCastri [1887-1968]).
An investigation was opened in May 1963.
An investigation was opened in May 1963.
 |
| John (L) and Alex D'Alessio Press |
On June 14, 1963 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that both Vincent Sarullo and Philip LiCastri are partners in the operation of the Club Trio, although the latter's name does not appear as one of the owners. He stated Sarullo has been handling policy, horse bets, bets on sporting events and in addition has been doing a heavy loan shark business. He noted Johnny Dee [D'Alessio] for one, is heavily indebted to Sarullo, reputedly for $18,000. Johnny Dee was in such bad financial straits, the local sheriff had orders to seize his vending machines and he was saved by a loan from his brother, [Alex aka] Pope Dee. He noted in addition to the operation of the Club Trio and his gambling operations, Sarullo also has a profitable trucking business son Jefferson Ave." [John (1912-1994) and Alex D'Alessio (1914-2015) were Gambino Soldiers.]
On November 21, 1963 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo], who is more commonly known as 'Jimmy', is friendly with the Dee [D'Alessio] brothers and with Joseph LaForte, and he is a heavy bettor at the race tracks, particularly the trotters...[CI] also noted that at one time Sarullo was the shop steward for the Carpenters Union at the Brooklyn Army Base. He stated he believed this was during the late 1940s."
On January 21, 1964 the New York Police Department advised the FBI's New York Office: "[Detective] advised Vincent Sarullo is engaged in loansharking operations at the Club Trio but this office has no information he is involved in the gambling rackets."
Over the next decade an FBI source close to Sarullo provided updates on his activities and also passed along various bits of LCN-related gossip.
On November 21, 1963 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo], who is more commonly known as 'Jimmy', is friendly with the Dee [D'Alessio] brothers and with Joseph LaForte, and he is a heavy bettor at the race tracks, particularly the trotters...[CI] also noted that at one time Sarullo was the shop steward for the Carpenters Union at the Brooklyn Army Base. He stated he believed this was during the late 1940s."
On January 21, 1964 the New York Police Department advised the FBI's New York Office: "[Detective] advised Vincent Sarullo is engaged in loansharking operations at the Club Trio but this office has no information he is involved in the gambling rackets."
Over the next decade an FBI source close to Sarullo provided updates on his activities and also passed along various bits of LCN-related gossip.
On January 21, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised Vincent Sarullo continues to operate a loansharking racket in addition to running a book on horse bets and sporting events. He stated he has no information Sarullo is currently involved in policy. He noted Sarullo's operations are conducted out of the Club Trio and this tavern is a hangout for local gamblers."
On January 21, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] stated Vincent Sarullo is still doing a large loanshark business out of the Club Trio, but he has no additional information on his gambling activities."
On January 27, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still active in loansharking but he has no info that he is involved in any of the gambling rackets. He advised he has also learned Sarullo has a warehouse located in the Elm Park area, about a block off Morningstar Road, but he has been unable to locate the specific address. He stated he is also endeavoring to determine whether the warehouse is used legitimately as part of the trucking operation or whether it is for illegal purposes."
On March 11, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is loaning money to local gamblers at the usual loanshark rates, and is also participating in taking bets on horse racing and sporting events."
On March 16, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he has determined the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Company, Inc., which is partially owned by Sarullo, has about five or six trucks and they do most of the trucking for the Ansbacker-Siegle Corp and the Sun Chemical Corp. He noted Sarullo's associate in this business is [Redacted] who actually takes care of the trucking operations and is considered a hard working, industrious and honest type of individual. Sarullo, on the other hand, takes no active part in the management of the company."
On March 18, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised Vincent Sarullo continues to be one of the most active loansharks on the South Shore. He stated he has observed a number of the local bookmakers and gamblers hanging out in the Club Trio, which Sarullo operates."
On January 21, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] stated Vincent Sarullo is still doing a large loanshark business out of the Club Trio, but he has no additional information on his gambling activities."
On January 27, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still active in loansharking but he has no info that he is involved in any of the gambling rackets. He advised he has also learned Sarullo has a warehouse located in the Elm Park area, about a block off Morningstar Road, but he has been unable to locate the specific address. He stated he is also endeavoring to determine whether the warehouse is used legitimately as part of the trucking operation or whether it is for illegal purposes."
On March 11, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is loaning money to local gamblers at the usual loanshark rates, and is also participating in taking bets on horse racing and sporting events."
On March 16, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he has determined the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Company, Inc., which is partially owned by Sarullo, has about five or six trucks and they do most of the trucking for the Ansbacker-Siegle Corp and the Sun Chemical Corp. He noted Sarullo's associate in this business is [Redacted] who actually takes care of the trucking operations and is considered a hard working, industrious and honest type of individual. Sarullo, on the other hand, takes no active part in the management of the company."
On March 18, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised Vincent Sarullo continues to be one of the most active loansharks on the South Shore. He stated he has observed a number of the local bookmakers and gamblers hanging out in the Club Trio, which Sarullo operates."
 |
| 1960s |
On May 15, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still active in the loanshark racket and is probably the biggest operator among the gambling element in Staten Island. He noted Johnny Dee [D'Alessio] is reported to be still heavily in debt to Sarullo. He noted Sarullo's trucking operation appears to be a legitimate business and there is no indication he is engaged in any other illicit activity."
On May 22, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still active in handling bookmaking and also wagers on sporting events. He noted [Redacted] is one of his active runners. He stated Sarullo frequents the tracks and in particular the trotters."
On September 16, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still engaged in loansharking, but he has no info he is involved in any other criminal activity. He stated that Sarullo's tavern, the Club Trio, is a hangout for gamblers and bookmakers, and it is mainly to this type of individual Sarullo has been making usurious loans. He noted Johnny Dee [D'Alessio] is still deeply indebted to Sarullo as a result of heavy losses at the racetrack which made it necessary for him to borrow from Sarullo to keep his creditors from seizing his vending machine business."
On September 17, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues active as a loanshark and gambler, operating out of the Club Trio...He stated Sarullo's gambling activities are principally concerned with sporting events but he has some horse betting rackets going for him, principally in the South Beach and East Shore areas."
On November 25, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the biggest loanshark in operation in the Staten Island area. He noted that Sarullo's customers include gamblers as well as local businessmen."
On December 11, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is engaged in the operation of a numbers racket between Staten Island and Bayonne, New Jersey with individuals who have been identified: [Redacted List]."
By 1965 subject of an interstate gambling investigation.
On January 11, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Jimmy Serillo [is] undoubtedly Jimmy Sarullo, aka Vincent Sarullo, who operates the Club Trio [across] from Crocitto's Tavern." (Crocitto's was owned by Mario Crocitto [1918-1990] from Bari, Puglia. In April 1975 Gambino Associate Thomas Bilotti was identified as the 'undisclosed owner'. In February 1976 it was reported that John D'Alessio frequented the location 'from which is run a gambling operation and other criminal activity'. A Gambino Soldier, named redacted, owned the business. In October 1980 Bilotti, then a made member, used Crocitto's auto when bringing Gambino Boss Paul Castellano to a meeting with the Bonanno Family.)
On March 9, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[He] has determined additional information regarding Vincent Sarullo's operation of the loan rackets in Staten Island. He noted that an applicant for a loan is referred to Sarullo, who questions him closely regarding his financial matters and purpose of the loan. Sarullo does not give the applicant any final answer, but refers him to one of his front men, such as [Redacted]. The latter in the meantime has received his instructions from Sarullo and when the application has been approved by Sarullo, he will instruct his front man to give the applicant his money. The payments on the loan are then made to the front man who gave the borrower his money in the first instance. In no case does Sarullo actually pay out the money to the borrower or accept payment. CI stated Sarullo's rates are lower than the usual loanshark, and he usually is content on 1% per week. He noted that many of the individuals who have bought dump trucks and bulldozers have had Sarullo finance the operation."
On May 22, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still active in handling bookmaking and also wagers on sporting events. He noted [Redacted] is one of his active runners. He stated Sarullo frequents the tracks and in particular the trotters."
On September 16, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still engaged in loansharking, but he has no info he is involved in any other criminal activity. He stated that Sarullo's tavern, the Club Trio, is a hangout for gamblers and bookmakers, and it is mainly to this type of individual Sarullo has been making usurious loans. He noted Johnny Dee [D'Alessio] is still deeply indebted to Sarullo as a result of heavy losses at the racetrack which made it necessary for him to borrow from Sarullo to keep his creditors from seizing his vending machine business."
On September 17, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues active as a loanshark and gambler, operating out of the Club Trio...He stated Sarullo's gambling activities are principally concerned with sporting events but he has some horse betting rackets going for him, principally in the South Beach and East Shore areas."
On November 25, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the biggest loanshark in operation in the Staten Island area. He noted that Sarullo's customers include gamblers as well as local businessmen."
On December 11, 1964 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is engaged in the operation of a numbers racket between Staten Island and Bayonne, New Jersey with individuals who have been identified: [Redacted List]."
By 1965 subject of an interstate gambling investigation.
On January 11, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Jimmy Serillo [is] undoubtedly Jimmy Sarullo, aka Vincent Sarullo, who operates the Club Trio [across] from Crocitto's Tavern." (Crocitto's was owned by Mario Crocitto [1918-1990] from Bari, Puglia. In April 1975 Gambino Associate Thomas Bilotti was identified as the 'undisclosed owner'. In February 1976 it was reported that John D'Alessio frequented the location 'from which is run a gambling operation and other criminal activity'. A Gambino Soldier, named redacted, owned the business. In October 1980 Bilotti, then a made member, used Crocitto's auto when bringing Gambino Boss Paul Castellano to a meeting with the Bonanno Family.)
On March 9, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[He] has determined additional information regarding Vincent Sarullo's operation of the loan rackets in Staten Island. He noted that an applicant for a loan is referred to Sarullo, who questions him closely regarding his financial matters and purpose of the loan. Sarullo does not give the applicant any final answer, but refers him to one of his front men, such as [Redacted]. The latter in the meantime has received his instructions from Sarullo and when the application has been approved by Sarullo, he will instruct his front man to give the applicant his money. The payments on the loan are then made to the front man who gave the borrower his money in the first instance. In no case does Sarullo actually pay out the money to the borrower or accept payment. CI stated Sarullo's rates are lower than the usual loanshark, and he usually is content on 1% per week. He noted that many of the individuals who have bought dump trucks and bulldozers have had Sarullo finance the operation."
 |
| J. LaForte |
On April 1, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised there is every indication that the LiCastris will take over control of the numbers racket from Joseph LaForte. He noted that about a year ago, the LiCastris appeared to be replacing LaForte, but the latter had too strong backing and was able to retain his position. However, [CI] noted LaForte has been bothered by a bad heart condition and in addition he was very close to Tony Bender, and with the latter's disappearance he has lost one of his biggest supporters. On the other hand, Vincent LiCastri has been very friendly with Peter Ferrara and with others in the Gambino Family. He has also teamed up with Jimmy Sarullo, another member of the Gambino Family, and the report is that the LiCastris will assume control over the entire numbers operation in Staten Island within the near future." (Joseph 'The Cat' LaForte [1917-2016] was then a proposed Associate under Captain Joseph Gennaro. After Gennaro died in 1968 LaForte was reporting directly to Underboss Aniello Dellacroce. He was inducted after the books re-opened in 1976.)
On June 16, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he still has not been able to resolve the question of whether Vincent Sarullo has taken control over all of the policy racket in Staten Island from Joseph LaForte. He stated that he has spoken to a number of bookmakers and has received conflicting answers...He said it appears Charles LiCastri has the most authority, and it will be he who will run the Staten Island policy if Sarullo is successful in driving LaForte out of this racket. [CI] further stated that he has heard Charles LiCastri has acted as the guarantor of several loans made recently by Jimmy Sarullo but LiCastri will not loanshark in competition to Sarullo. He stated these two are close friends and are reported to assisting each other wherever possible."
On June 16, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he still has not been able to resolve the question of whether Vincent Sarullo has taken control over all of the policy racket in Staten Island from Joseph LaForte. He stated that he has spoken to a number of bookmakers and has received conflicting answers...He said it appears Charles LiCastri has the most authority, and it will be he who will run the Staten Island policy if Sarullo is successful in driving LaForte out of this racket. [CI] further stated that he has heard Charles LiCastri has acted as the guarantor of several loans made recently by Jimmy Sarullo but LiCastri will not loanshark in competition to Sarullo. He stated these two are close friends and are reported to assisting each other wherever possible."
 |
| A. DiBrizzi FBN Mafia Book |
On October 5, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[He] has just received reliable info that Alex DiBrizzi recently borrowed $5,000 from Jimmy Sarullo, South Beach loanshark. He stated he has no information why DiBrizzi should be hard pressed for money at this time, but will make further inquiries and will advise if any info is developed." (Alex DiBrizzi [1892-1981] was another made member active in SI.)
On December 13, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the leading figure in the local loanshark racket, and [Redacted] fronts for him in loaning out money and collecting payments from borrowers."
On December 13, 1965 FBI CI reported: "...[CI] further advised that [redacted] the Club Trio, 272 Sand Lane, South Beach where many of the hoods from the Lower East Side [of Manhattan] gather every Sunday afternoon. He stated this club is run by Jimmy Sarullo, local loanshark, and [Redacted] frequented this tavern."
On December 17, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] aka [Redacted] has been working for Vincent Sarullo as an enforcer [redacted]. He noted [Redacted] has a criminal record for gambling and handling illegal alcohol."
On December 17, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] does not take an active part in running [trucking company] and the business is all handled by [Redacted]."
On December 22, 1965 FBI CI reported: "...With reference to [Redacted], CI identified him as [Redacted] who works for Jimmy Sarullo in his loanshark operation at the Club Trio."
On February 9, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] has been picking up bets at the Rosebank Club, 521 Tompkins Avenue. He stated [Redacted] is an associate of Jimmy Sarullo and can frequently be seen in Sarullo's [club]."
On July 19, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[CI] noted [Vincent Sarullo]'s residence is within a block of [Club Trio]. He advised that Sarullo continues as an active loanshark and is in fact the biggest shylock in the Staten Island area. He said that Vincent LiCastri is a close associate of Sarullo, and LiCastri is active in the local policy rackets and is the son of Philip LiCastri, who is also reported to be a button man in the organization."
On July 21, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues as a partner in the operation of the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Co., with a warehouse at 558 Granite Avenue...He noted, however, while previously Sarullo was content to let his partner run the operation, lately he has been taking a more active interest in the business and has been trying to build up the company. He stated Sarullo has been insisting the profits be put back in the company to purchase new trucks and to modernize the warehouse and other equipment. He noted a major part of the business of this company comes from Ansbacher-Siegal Corp, Chestnut Avenue, SI."
On October 31, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] reported to be a button man [and] is also known to be loansharking in this area, his front man being [Redacted] at the Club Trio. [CI] advised [Redacted] has been accepting bets on sporting events, [redacted] is very careful to accept wagers only when there are no strangers around, and [redacted]. [CI] stated Sarullo is very friendly with Vincent LiCastri, and he has heard the latter is either a button man, or his father is in the organization. He noted further [Redacted] formerly worked with Sarullo as an enforcer in his loanshark racket, but [Redacted] has not been around in recent months."
On March 2, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[18 Balfour St] has been the [Sarullo] family residence for years, and is located in a lower middle class neighborhood, only a block from Sarullo's tavern. [CI] noted Sarullo continues to be friendly with Vincent LiCastri, son of Philip LiCastri, reputed to be a 'button man' in the Gambino Family."
On March 3, 1967 NYPD advised FBI: "[Detective] advised that Vincent Sarullo is reported to be friendly with Vincent LiCastri, Mario DiGiorgio and [Redacted]. He stated Mario DiGiorgio is the former operator of the Silver Dollar Tavern, 2481 Richmond Road, SI, which was a meeting place for local hoodlums, and also has [criminal record]."
On March 8, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is definitely a button man with LCN, and has been operating as a loanshark for at least ten years. He stated that [Redacted] at the Club Trio, Sarullo's tavern, is Sarullo's contact man with regard to loans, Sarullo himself does not handle any money, and accordingly no one can ever testify against him. He said [Redacted] accepts bets on horses and sporting events in the tavern, but does not operate on a big scale. He stated despite Sarullo's shylocking operations, he is very well regarded around Staten Island, since he will not push for payment if he feels the borrower does not have the money, and will also waive any accumulation of interest when the debt is not repaid on time."
On July 10, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[He] has observed Vincent Sarullo and his wife dining at the Mark Chinese Restaurant, 1816 Hylan Blvd [and] he has heard a report that Sarullo has an interest in this spot. He said he has not been able to verify this report up to the present time. He said he has also heard the proprietor of this restaurant formerly operated in Chinatown, Manhattan and his place was a hangout for hoods from the Lower East Side. He said the proprietor is [Redacted]. He stated he has also heard Paul Castellano and James Failla also hang out at the Mark Chinese Restaurant, in addition to Sarullo." (Earlier that year Castellano was appointed Gambino Acting Boss. At the same time Joseph Gennaro's crew was split, with about half going to the newly promoted Failla.)
On July 12, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues very active in the loanshark rackets and [Redacted] has been handling some of these loans on the waterfront. He said [Redacted] has been fronting for Sarullo on some of these loans."
On July 24, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[CI] noted that Philip LiCastri's two sons, Vincent and Charles LiCastri are close friends of Jimmy Sarullo, and are frequently observed in the latter's tavern, the Club Trio."
On October 16, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues as the biggest figure in the local loan shark racket, and [Redacted] has been acting as his front man in this racket. He stated [Redacted] handles a great deal of betting on sporting events [redacted]."
On November 21, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is active in the loanshark racket, and shylocks to local businessmen, gamblers and individuals in the contracting line, especially builders. He noted that Johnny Pietracatella, who works in the construction line, fronts for Sarullo, passes out the money and makes the collections so there will be no legal evidence connecting Sarullo to the racket." (Pietracatella [1940-2004] was Sarullo's son-in-law.)
On August 1, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Daniel] Maschietto owes $800 to Jimmy Sarullo...Maschietto was on a bat for eight days and no one knew where he was during this time, and Sarullo has started to press him for the money. He said he does not know if Maschietto has handled any loot, [redacted]."
On August 1, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised [redacted] stated Vincent Sarullo has indicated to him that he has about $250,000 outstanding in loans in his loansharking operation, including $20,000 to Pope Dee [Alex D'Alessio], $15,000 to Anthony DeSimone, operator of the Marlin Ship Storage, Inc., 34 Prospect St [and] $12,000 to the operator of Curly's Restaurant, Bay Street, Staten Island. [CI] said that Sarullo has told him that he has loaned money to three doctors in Staten Island and also to unidentified police officers in this area. He said Sarullo is the owner of the National Amusement Co., 278 Sand Lane, a vending machine company, but operates this company through a front. He stated Sarullo is also the owner of the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Company [run] by [Redacted], but has complained [Redacted] is holding out on the profits, [redacted]. With reference to Pope Dee's loan, [CI] said this loan is in default, and he expects Sarullo to take some action against Pope Dee within the next week or two unless arrangements are made within the near future for payments. He advised Sarullo recently attempted to buy the Towne House Restaurant in [SI], but the deal fell through because the current owner was insistent on getting all cash on the line at the time of purchase whereas Sarullo wanted to put off part of the payment."
On August 12, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the biggest loanshark in Staten Island, and he continues to be a close associate of Vincent and Charles LiCastri, who operate a policy racket out of [LiCastri Bakery] which is located within a block of Sarullo's tavern." (The LiCastris' father Philip died that March.)
In September 1968 included in the FBI's list of 205 identified Gambino Family members.
On October 14, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo], Vinnie and [Redacted] were in partnership in booking football games but their losses up to a week ago were over $40,000. He said while they continue to accept bets on football games, they now turn the proceeds to someone from the Brooklyn area."
On October 14, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[He] has definitely determined that Joe 'The Cat' LaForte, boss of the numbers racket in Staten Island, who formerly operated under 'Joe the Wop' Gennaro, is now working for Aniello Dellacroce. [CI] said his source for this information is Jimmy Sarullo, a [Gambino] button."
On December 11, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is reportedly considering selling the Club Trio and buying a bar or a restaurant in Manhattan or one of the other boroughs. He stated that Sarullo was also said to be interested in the Skyway Lounge at [JFK Airport], but he does not know if he has made a specific offer for this place."
On January 13, 1969 Sarullo was interviewed by FBI Agents: "He advised he has been residing at his current residence for the past 48 years. He attended Public School 39, South Beach, graduating in 1932. He was then a student at Curtis High School for about one year, and has had no further education...Sarullo explained he has owned the Club Trio since 1953 but has devoted full time to its operation only since 1960...He advised this arrangement has been set up for the operation of his tavern. His father opens in the morning and handles everything until noon, when he personally takes over. The night bartender, [Redacted] aka [Redacted] comes in about 6:00 PM, and remains until closing time. He stated he, Sarullo, usually stays around the tavern all afternoon and evening. He denied any affiliation with organized crime and specifically denied membership in the Gambino Family of La Cosa Nostra. He stated that he did not know a Carlo Gambino, Paul Castellano or Pete Ferrara, but he admitted being friendly with Vincent and Charles LiCastri who he said operate a bakery near his tavern. He denied knowledge that they were involved in the policy rackets."
On March 4, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still reported to be considering selling the Club Trio and buying a bar in Manhattan or Brooklyn. He noted Sarullo feels he receives too much attention from LE agencies in SI, whereas if he moved to a more populated area of the city, he would be lost in the crowd."
On April 2, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Despite] the fact Sarullo charges usurious rates, he is considered by his clients to be a legitimate operator in that his rates are moderate as compared to other loansharks, he has never used intimidation to force payment, he will not press anyone for payment if he feels the debtor is making an honest effort to live up to his obligations, and he will help individuals who cannot obtain credit elsewhere. He stated Sarullo has been responsible for carrying many businessmen over periods of temporary financial crisis, and thus enable them to retain their businesses when otherwise they might have been wiped out."
On April 4, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues to operate his loanshark racket out of his tavern, and he has about $250,000 outstanding in loans at this time. He said Sarullo has told him he is worth over a million dollars. He noted Sarullo's closest associates are Vincent & Charles LiCastri, who operate a policy racket out of their bakery...He noted Sarullo has been talking about selling the Club Trio and buying a tavern in Manhattan or Brooklyn, because he receives too much attention from the local police in Staten Island. He stated Sarullo is reported to have a financial interest in a laundromat in the South Beach area."
On April 23, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Jimmy Sarullo informed him that Alex D'Alessio still owes him $18,000, he has repeatedly granted him extensions of time but D'Alessio still has not paid up. Sarullo noted that D'Alessio is not protected, that neither he nor his brothers, Mikey and Johnny Dee, are members of the LCN, and he therefore will not have to sit down with anyone to discuss repayment of the debt. [CI] stated although Sarullo appears to be angry with D'Alessio, he has not mentioned taking any action against him." (Various government reports and charts over the years have listed the D'Alessio brothers as members.)
On May 14, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] has learned that Vincent Sarullo is the owner of the Staten Island Amusement Company, 59 St. Marys Ave...He stated he learned of his interest in this company when Sarullo told him he was having trouble with LaMorte's Music Service, Inc., who have been trying to take over some of the stops of the Staten Island Amusement Co. He stated Sarullo also told him Pope Dee [D'Alessio] has still not paid up on his $18,000 debt, and is making no effort to pay."
On December 13, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the leading figure in the local loanshark racket, and [Redacted] fronts for him in loaning out money and collecting payments from borrowers."
On December 13, 1965 FBI CI reported: "...[CI] further advised that [redacted] the Club Trio, 272 Sand Lane, South Beach where many of the hoods from the Lower East Side [of Manhattan] gather every Sunday afternoon. He stated this club is run by Jimmy Sarullo, local loanshark, and [Redacted] frequented this tavern."
On December 17, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] aka [Redacted] has been working for Vincent Sarullo as an enforcer [redacted]. He noted [Redacted] has a criminal record for gambling and handling illegal alcohol."
On December 17, 1965 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] does not take an active part in running [trucking company] and the business is all handled by [Redacted]."
On December 22, 1965 FBI CI reported: "...With reference to [Redacted], CI identified him as [Redacted] who works for Jimmy Sarullo in his loanshark operation at the Club Trio."
On February 9, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] has been picking up bets at the Rosebank Club, 521 Tompkins Avenue. He stated [Redacted] is an associate of Jimmy Sarullo and can frequently be seen in Sarullo's [club]."
On July 19, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[CI] noted [Vincent Sarullo]'s residence is within a block of [Club Trio]. He advised that Sarullo continues as an active loanshark and is in fact the biggest shylock in the Staten Island area. He said that Vincent LiCastri is a close associate of Sarullo, and LiCastri is active in the local policy rackets and is the son of Philip LiCastri, who is also reported to be a button man in the organization."
On July 21, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues as a partner in the operation of the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Co., with a warehouse at 558 Granite Avenue...He noted, however, while previously Sarullo was content to let his partner run the operation, lately he has been taking a more active interest in the business and has been trying to build up the company. He stated Sarullo has been insisting the profits be put back in the company to purchase new trucks and to modernize the warehouse and other equipment. He noted a major part of the business of this company comes from Ansbacher-Siegal Corp, Chestnut Avenue, SI."
On October 31, 1966 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] reported to be a button man [and] is also known to be loansharking in this area, his front man being [Redacted] at the Club Trio. [CI] advised [Redacted] has been accepting bets on sporting events, [redacted] is very careful to accept wagers only when there are no strangers around, and [redacted]. [CI] stated Sarullo is very friendly with Vincent LiCastri, and he has heard the latter is either a button man, or his father is in the organization. He noted further [Redacted] formerly worked with Sarullo as an enforcer in his loanshark racket, but [Redacted] has not been around in recent months."
On March 2, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[18 Balfour St] has been the [Sarullo] family residence for years, and is located in a lower middle class neighborhood, only a block from Sarullo's tavern. [CI] noted Sarullo continues to be friendly with Vincent LiCastri, son of Philip LiCastri, reputed to be a 'button man' in the Gambino Family."
On March 3, 1967 NYPD advised FBI: "[Detective] advised that Vincent Sarullo is reported to be friendly with Vincent LiCastri, Mario DiGiorgio and [Redacted]. He stated Mario DiGiorgio is the former operator of the Silver Dollar Tavern, 2481 Richmond Road, SI, which was a meeting place for local hoodlums, and also has [criminal record]."
On March 8, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is definitely a button man with LCN, and has been operating as a loanshark for at least ten years. He stated that [Redacted] at the Club Trio, Sarullo's tavern, is Sarullo's contact man with regard to loans, Sarullo himself does not handle any money, and accordingly no one can ever testify against him. He said [Redacted] accepts bets on horses and sporting events in the tavern, but does not operate on a big scale. He stated despite Sarullo's shylocking operations, he is very well regarded around Staten Island, since he will not push for payment if he feels the borrower does not have the money, and will also waive any accumulation of interest when the debt is not repaid on time."
On July 10, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[He] has observed Vincent Sarullo and his wife dining at the Mark Chinese Restaurant, 1816 Hylan Blvd [and] he has heard a report that Sarullo has an interest in this spot. He said he has not been able to verify this report up to the present time. He said he has also heard the proprietor of this restaurant formerly operated in Chinatown, Manhattan and his place was a hangout for hoods from the Lower East Side. He said the proprietor is [Redacted]. He stated he has also heard Paul Castellano and James Failla also hang out at the Mark Chinese Restaurant, in addition to Sarullo." (Earlier that year Castellano was appointed Gambino Acting Boss. At the same time Joseph Gennaro's crew was split, with about half going to the newly promoted Failla.)
On July 12, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues very active in the loanshark rackets and [Redacted] has been handling some of these loans on the waterfront. He said [Redacted] has been fronting for Sarullo on some of these loans."
On July 24, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[CI] noted that Philip LiCastri's two sons, Vincent and Charles LiCastri are close friends of Jimmy Sarullo, and are frequently observed in the latter's tavern, the Club Trio."
On October 16, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues as the biggest figure in the local loan shark racket, and [Redacted] has been acting as his front man in this racket. He stated [Redacted] handles a great deal of betting on sporting events [redacted]."
On November 21, 1967 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is active in the loanshark racket, and shylocks to local businessmen, gamblers and individuals in the contracting line, especially builders. He noted that Johnny Pietracatella, who works in the construction line, fronts for Sarullo, passes out the money and makes the collections so there will be no legal evidence connecting Sarullo to the racket." (Pietracatella [1940-2004] was Sarullo's son-in-law.)
On August 1, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Daniel] Maschietto owes $800 to Jimmy Sarullo...Maschietto was on a bat for eight days and no one knew where he was during this time, and Sarullo has started to press him for the money. He said he does not know if Maschietto has handled any loot, [redacted]."
On August 1, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised [redacted] stated Vincent Sarullo has indicated to him that he has about $250,000 outstanding in loans in his loansharking operation, including $20,000 to Pope Dee [Alex D'Alessio], $15,000 to Anthony DeSimone, operator of the Marlin Ship Storage, Inc., 34 Prospect St [and] $12,000 to the operator of Curly's Restaurant, Bay Street, Staten Island. [CI] said that Sarullo has told him that he has loaned money to three doctors in Staten Island and also to unidentified police officers in this area. He said Sarullo is the owner of the National Amusement Co., 278 Sand Lane, a vending machine company, but operates this company through a front. He stated Sarullo is also the owner of the Benigno & Sarullo Trucking Company [run] by [Redacted], but has complained [Redacted] is holding out on the profits, [redacted]. With reference to Pope Dee's loan, [CI] said this loan is in default, and he expects Sarullo to take some action against Pope Dee within the next week or two unless arrangements are made within the near future for payments. He advised Sarullo recently attempted to buy the Towne House Restaurant in [SI], but the deal fell through because the current owner was insistent on getting all cash on the line at the time of purchase whereas Sarullo wanted to put off part of the payment."
On August 12, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is the biggest loanshark in Staten Island, and he continues to be a close associate of Vincent and Charles LiCastri, who operate a policy racket out of [LiCastri Bakery] which is located within a block of Sarullo's tavern." (The LiCastris' father Philip died that March.)
In September 1968 included in the FBI's list of 205 identified Gambino Family members.
On October 14, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo], Vinnie and [Redacted] were in partnership in booking football games but their losses up to a week ago were over $40,000. He said while they continue to accept bets on football games, they now turn the proceeds to someone from the Brooklyn area."
On October 14, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[He] has definitely determined that Joe 'The Cat' LaForte, boss of the numbers racket in Staten Island, who formerly operated under 'Joe the Wop' Gennaro, is now working for Aniello Dellacroce. [CI] said his source for this information is Jimmy Sarullo, a [Gambino] button."
On December 11, 1968 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is reportedly considering selling the Club Trio and buying a bar or a restaurant in Manhattan or one of the other boroughs. He stated that Sarullo was also said to be interested in the Skyway Lounge at [JFK Airport], but he does not know if he has made a specific offer for this place."
On January 13, 1969 Sarullo was interviewed by FBI Agents: "He advised he has been residing at his current residence for the past 48 years. He attended Public School 39, South Beach, graduating in 1932. He was then a student at Curtis High School for about one year, and has had no further education...Sarullo explained he has owned the Club Trio since 1953 but has devoted full time to its operation only since 1960...He advised this arrangement has been set up for the operation of his tavern. His father opens in the morning and handles everything until noon, when he personally takes over. The night bartender, [Redacted] aka [Redacted] comes in about 6:00 PM, and remains until closing time. He stated he, Sarullo, usually stays around the tavern all afternoon and evening. He denied any affiliation with organized crime and specifically denied membership in the Gambino Family of La Cosa Nostra. He stated that he did not know a Carlo Gambino, Paul Castellano or Pete Ferrara, but he admitted being friendly with Vincent and Charles LiCastri who he said operate a bakery near his tavern. He denied knowledge that they were involved in the policy rackets."
On March 4, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is still reported to be considering selling the Club Trio and buying a bar in Manhattan or Brooklyn. He noted Sarullo feels he receives too much attention from LE agencies in SI, whereas if he moved to a more populated area of the city, he would be lost in the crowd."
On April 2, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Despite] the fact Sarullo charges usurious rates, he is considered by his clients to be a legitimate operator in that his rates are moderate as compared to other loansharks, he has never used intimidation to force payment, he will not press anyone for payment if he feels the debtor is making an honest effort to live up to his obligations, and he will help individuals who cannot obtain credit elsewhere. He stated Sarullo has been responsible for carrying many businessmen over periods of temporary financial crisis, and thus enable them to retain their businesses when otherwise they might have been wiped out."
On April 4, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] continues to operate his loanshark racket out of his tavern, and he has about $250,000 outstanding in loans at this time. He said Sarullo has told him he is worth over a million dollars. He noted Sarullo's closest associates are Vincent & Charles LiCastri, who operate a policy racket out of their bakery...He noted Sarullo has been talking about selling the Club Trio and buying a tavern in Manhattan or Brooklyn, because he receives too much attention from the local police in Staten Island. He stated Sarullo is reported to have a financial interest in a laundromat in the South Beach area."
On April 23, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Jimmy Sarullo informed him that Alex D'Alessio still owes him $18,000, he has repeatedly granted him extensions of time but D'Alessio still has not paid up. Sarullo noted that D'Alessio is not protected, that neither he nor his brothers, Mikey and Johnny Dee, are members of the LCN, and he therefore will not have to sit down with anyone to discuss repayment of the debt. [CI] stated although Sarullo appears to be angry with D'Alessio, he has not mentioned taking any action against him." (Various government reports and charts over the years have listed the D'Alessio brothers as members.)
On May 14, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] has learned that Vincent Sarullo is the owner of the Staten Island Amusement Company, 59 St. Marys Ave...He stated he learned of his interest in this company when Sarullo told him he was having trouble with LaMorte's Music Service, Inc., who have been trying to take over some of the stops of the Staten Island Amusement Co. He stated Sarullo also told him Pope Dee [D'Alessio] has still not paid up on his $18,000 debt, and is making no effort to pay."
 |
| F. Tieri |
On June 10, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Jimmy Sarullo, button in Gambino Family, informed him that Frank Tieri had been designated as Boss of Genovese Family. According to Sarullo, a celebration was held last week at an unknown location, at which all the top members of LCN were present."
On September 22, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] has determined Vincent Sarullo's Capo is Giuseppe Traina, who lives on 76th Street, between 11th and 12th Avenue [in Brooklyn]." (An FBI member source reported in September 1968 that Traina's son Mario had replaced him as Captain.)
On October 1, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] uses the Club Trio to push shylock money and make book. [CI] said Sarullo has a lucrative shylocking operation on Staten Island and reportedly has 100- 200 thousand on the street in loans. CI said Sarullo has a bodyguard, [Redacted] (LNU), [redacted]."
On October 16, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Vincent] and Charles LiCastri are friends with Jimmy Sarullo and are frequently seen at Sarullo's Club Trio. [CI] said the LiCastris are making book near the Club Trio."
In November 1969 included in the FBI's list of 233 identified Gambino Family members.
On September 22, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] has determined Vincent Sarullo's Capo is Giuseppe Traina, who lives on 76th Street, between 11th and 12th Avenue [in Brooklyn]." (An FBI member source reported in September 1968 that Traina's son Mario had replaced him as Captain.)
On October 1, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] uses the Club Trio to push shylock money and make book. [CI] said Sarullo has a lucrative shylocking operation on Staten Island and reportedly has 100- 200 thousand on the street in loans. CI said Sarullo has a bodyguard, [Redacted] (LNU), [redacted]."
On October 16, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[Vincent] and Charles LiCastri are friends with Jimmy Sarullo and are frequently seen at Sarullo's Club Trio. [CI] said the LiCastris are making book near the Club Trio."
In November 1969 included in the FBI's list of 233 identified Gambino Family members.
On February 16, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised Vincent Sarullo, [Redacted] (ph) who is [redacted] Charles LiCastri, and Red Traina, son of Giuseppe Traina, are in the process of buying the Intermission Cafe in Brooklyn. He noted the purchase will probably be made under someone else's name, but as yet no decision has been made on that front." (The cafe was formerly operated by Traina crew member Paul SanFilippo who died in 1968.)
 |
| A. Meli |
On March 16, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Angelo] Meli has been hanging out in the Silver Dollar Restaurant, 2481 Richmond Road, [with] [Redacted] and Mario DiGiorgio, the owner of the Silver Dollar...DiGiorgio owes money to Jimmy Sarullo on a shylock loan, and another individual who owes money to Sarullo is [Redacted]." (Angelo Meli [1930-2014] was a Soldier in Olympio 'Lilo' Garofalo's crew.)
On April 9, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] again advised that Frank Tieri has been selected as head of the Genovese Family. He noted this information has been verified by both Jimmy Sarullo and Edward Consalvo, both buttons in the Gambino Family." (Edward 'Ottawa' Consalvo [1920-1981] was a Soldier in Michael 'Mike Tali' Caiazzo's crew.)
A couple of days later Joseph Traina's son Joseph Jr. died at his desk in Manhattan's Garment Center.
The wake was held April 15 at the Gambino-linked Cusimano and Russo Funeral Home in Gravesend. Attendees included Joseph Traina, Mario Traina, Vincent Sarullo and fellow Staten Island resident Ignazio 'Ralph' Pantano (1907-1989). (In July and September 1980 Pantano's auto was observed at Bonanno Captain Cesare Bonventre's Caffe Roma in Bensonhurst.)
On April 15, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Vincent] and Charles LiCastri use Vincent Sarullo's Club Trio as a hangout. He said the LiCastri's have a bakery on [SI] where money is taken from gambling operations and counted, and they are also operating a card game at this bakery. [CI] also advised that although Sarullo is shylocking, his customers would not give him up, inasmuch as Sarullo does not resort to the use of 'muscle' to claim repayment. [CI] said Sarullo is known to give numerous extensions of time on a given loan, without vig, if a victim is in a financially insolvent position and as a result, maintains excellent rapport with his customers."
On May 5, 1970 FBI reported: "[Sarullo] is very security minded and will not discuss his shylocking business over the telephone, making use of authorized electronic coverage of his telephone useless. The NYPD has in fact had coverage of Sarullo's telephone on several different occasions within the past few years but has found them unproductive."
On April 9, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] again advised that Frank Tieri has been selected as head of the Genovese Family. He noted this information has been verified by both Jimmy Sarullo and Edward Consalvo, both buttons in the Gambino Family." (Edward 'Ottawa' Consalvo [1920-1981] was a Soldier in Michael 'Mike Tali' Caiazzo's crew.)
A couple of days later Joseph Traina's son Joseph Jr. died at his desk in Manhattan's Garment Center.
The wake was held April 15 at the Gambino-linked Cusimano and Russo Funeral Home in Gravesend. Attendees included Joseph Traina, Mario Traina, Vincent Sarullo and fellow Staten Island resident Ignazio 'Ralph' Pantano (1907-1989). (In July and September 1980 Pantano's auto was observed at Bonanno Captain Cesare Bonventre's Caffe Roma in Bensonhurst.)
On April 15, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Vincent] and Charles LiCastri use Vincent Sarullo's Club Trio as a hangout. He said the LiCastri's have a bakery on [SI] where money is taken from gambling operations and counted, and they are also operating a card game at this bakery. [CI] also advised that although Sarullo is shylocking, his customers would not give him up, inasmuch as Sarullo does not resort to the use of 'muscle' to claim repayment. [CI] said Sarullo is known to give numerous extensions of time on a given loan, without vig, if a victim is in a financially insolvent position and as a result, maintains excellent rapport with his customers."
On May 5, 1970 FBI reported: "[Sarullo] is very security minded and will not discuss his shylocking business over the telephone, making use of authorized electronic coverage of his telephone useless. The NYPD has in fact had coverage of Sarullo's telephone on several different occasions within the past few years but has found them unproductive."
 |
| V. Gigante (c. 1970) |
On May 25, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] has been told by Jimmy Sarullo that Vincent Gigante is trying to take over the bookmaking operation among the construction workers at the site of the NYS Mental Hospital in [South Beach]. Sarullo indicated he believes this will be a lucrative piece of action, and he believes he should be entitled to it because of its location in his territory. Sarullo also stated it may be necessary to have a 'sit-down' to settle this dispute." (Vincent 'Chin' Gigante [1928-2005] was at the time a Soldier in the Genovese Family's Greenwich Village crew.)
A few days later the same informant reported a failed attempt by one of Sarullo's associates to use a deli located near the construction site as a headquarters to 'line up' customers.
On June 22, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[He] has learned title [of Intermission Cafe] will be taken in the name of [Redacted] as he has no criminal record and no obvious hoodlum connections. CI noted that [redacted] but this is not well known."
On July 10, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] has obtained his license from the State Liquor Authority to open up the Intermission Cafe in Brooklyn...[CI] also stated that Vincent Sarullo has lost out on the bookmaking operation at the site of the NYS Mental Hospital...CI stated this would have given Sarullo a clear field to handle all the bookmaking among the construction workers on this project. However, 'Chin' Gigante received the right and will control this bookmaking operation."
A few days later the same informant reported a failed attempt by one of Sarullo's associates to use a deli located near the construction site as a headquarters to 'line up' customers.
On June 22, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[He] has learned title [of Intermission Cafe] will be taken in the name of [Redacted] as he has no criminal record and no obvious hoodlum connections. CI noted that [redacted] but this is not well known."
On July 10, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] has obtained his license from the State Liquor Authority to open up the Intermission Cafe in Brooklyn...[CI] also stated that Vincent Sarullo has lost out on the bookmaking operation at the site of the NYS Mental Hospital...CI stated this would have given Sarullo a clear field to handle all the bookmaking among the construction workers on this project. However, 'Chin' Gigante received the right and will control this bookmaking operation."
 |
| A. Marinelli (1964) |
On August 19, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[He] questioned Jimmy Sarullo regarding Gus Marinelli, and Sarullo stated that Marinelli does not have any illegal rackets going for him at this time. According to Sarullo, Marinelli has a good job through his union, and appears to be satisfied with this setup at the present time." (Accursio 'Gus / Swifty' Marinelli [1911-1983] was a Soldier in Vincent 'Jimmy the Blond' Corrao's crew. Corrao took over from Joseph Gennaro after the latter's death in September 1968.)
On October 18, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has the Club Trio up for sale, but does not appear too anxious to dispose of it. He noted that he has received several offers which he has rejected on the basis the offers are too low."
On November 25, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Angelo Meli has been hanging out with [Redacted] in the Silver Dollar Restaurant...He noted Meli is very friendly with Mario DiGiorgio, operator of this restaurant, who has done time for handling narcotics. He stated further DiGiorgio and [Redacted] at [redacted] SI, both owe money to Jimmy Sarullo, the shylock who operates the Club Trio."
On May 24, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has pulled out of the operation of the Intermission Cafe. He noted [Redacted] actually has been the holder of the liquor license, but after a few months of operation, it became obvious [Redacted] was mishandling the finances, and Sarullo decided to sell out his share. [CI] also advised that Sarullo has been running a racket every Saturday night, featuring Italian food, at $5 a person. He noted that Sarullo is insistent on all his associates being present, and apparently does very well financially as the bar does a rushing business during these affairs."
On October 21, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[All] sports play on Staten Island goes to Vincent 'Jimmy' Sarullo according to [Redacted]. [Sarullo] is in partnership with Charles and Vincent LiCastri also of South Beach. [CI] states Charles LiCastri handles the horse and sports action while Vincent LiCastri handles the policy. [CI] states Sarullo is a partner in all the action and the LiCastri's are also partners with Sarullo in loanshark activities on Staten Island and Charles LiCastri can okay shylock loans. [CI] stated [Redacted] tried to place a man in [redacted] but he was chased out because the territory belonged to [Redacted]. [CI] stated Sarullo and LiCastri's are presently using [phone] to take horse and sport action." (On the basis of this information a gambling investigation was opened on Sarullo and LiCastri brothers.)
On November 19, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[Contact] with a bookmaker working for John Pate indicated all sports action was still going down the beach to the LiCastri's and Jimmy Sarullo. [CI] stated Charles LiCastri was handling horse and sports while Vinnie LiCastri ran the numbers and Sarullo ran the loanshark activity. [CI] stated Anthony LiCastri is out of the operation because he is considered too irresponsible...[CI] also advised that John Pietracatella, son-in-law of Sarullo, also works for Sarullo. [CI] stated Pietracatella is a former football player and is used mostly to collect on shylock loans. [CI] also advised [Redacted] handles policy and shylock loans for the LiCastri's and Sarullo in the South Beach area." (Anthony LiCastri [1929-1991] was a younger brother of Charles and Vincent. John Pate is believed referring to either the father or son of the same name, both of whom were Colombo Associates under Captain Charles 'Charlie Moose' Panarella. John Pate Jr. was inducted into the Colombos after the books opened in 1976 and became a Cooperating Witness in 1993.)
On October 18, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has the Club Trio up for sale, but does not appear too anxious to dispose of it. He noted that he has received several offers which he has rejected on the basis the offers are too low."
On November 25, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Angelo Meli has been hanging out with [Redacted] in the Silver Dollar Restaurant...He noted Meli is very friendly with Mario DiGiorgio, operator of this restaurant, who has done time for handling narcotics. He stated further DiGiorgio and [Redacted] at [redacted] SI, both owe money to Jimmy Sarullo, the shylock who operates the Club Trio."
On May 24, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has pulled out of the operation of the Intermission Cafe. He noted [Redacted] actually has been the holder of the liquor license, but after a few months of operation, it became obvious [Redacted] was mishandling the finances, and Sarullo decided to sell out his share. [CI] also advised that Sarullo has been running a racket every Saturday night, featuring Italian food, at $5 a person. He noted that Sarullo is insistent on all his associates being present, and apparently does very well financially as the bar does a rushing business during these affairs."
On October 21, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[All] sports play on Staten Island goes to Vincent 'Jimmy' Sarullo according to [Redacted]. [Sarullo] is in partnership with Charles and Vincent LiCastri also of South Beach. [CI] states Charles LiCastri handles the horse and sports action while Vincent LiCastri handles the policy. [CI] states Sarullo is a partner in all the action and the LiCastri's are also partners with Sarullo in loanshark activities on Staten Island and Charles LiCastri can okay shylock loans. [CI] stated [Redacted] tried to place a man in [redacted] but he was chased out because the territory belonged to [Redacted]. [CI] stated Sarullo and LiCastri's are presently using [phone] to take horse and sport action." (On the basis of this information a gambling investigation was opened on Sarullo and LiCastri brothers.)
On November 19, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[Contact] with a bookmaker working for John Pate indicated all sports action was still going down the beach to the LiCastri's and Jimmy Sarullo. [CI] stated Charles LiCastri was handling horse and sports while Vinnie LiCastri ran the numbers and Sarullo ran the loanshark activity. [CI] stated Anthony LiCastri is out of the operation because he is considered too irresponsible...[CI] also advised that John Pietracatella, son-in-law of Sarullo, also works for Sarullo. [CI] stated Pietracatella is a former football player and is used mostly to collect on shylock loans. [CI] also advised [Redacted] handles policy and shylock loans for the LiCastri's and Sarullo in the South Beach area." (Anthony LiCastri [1929-1991] was a younger brother of Charles and Vincent. John Pate is believed referring to either the father or son of the same name, both of whom were Colombo Associates under Captain Charles 'Charlie Moose' Panarella. John Pate Jr. was inducted into the Colombos after the books opened in 1976 and became a Cooperating Witness in 1993.)
 |
| L. Guiga (1969) |
On December 9, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[He] has observed Louis Guiga, a button in the Carlo Gambino Family, in the Club Trio talking to Sarullo. He noted that Guiga was discussing his problems with the IRS and indicated he is facing a six year jail term. [CI] also stated Sarullo is still engaged in shylocking activities and one individual who is pushing out shylock money for him is Louis Conte of Jersey Street, Staten Island. He noted Conte operates a market at 402 Jersey Street, and is considered to be a good producer for Sarullo." (Louis Guiga [1927-1980] was a Soldier in Vincent Corrao's crew.)
In January 8, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised [Redacted], who owed Vincent Sarullo $3,000 in loanshark money, skipped to Florida and Sarullo has been canvassing his friends to see who is heading to Florida so they can collect the debt from [Redacted]. He stated that Sarullo will always give his customers an extension of time if he feels they deserve it, but always sees red when somebody tried to beat him out of his money."
On May 25, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has been very quiet in recent months and has said he will lay low for awhile until the IRS has discontinued the investigation into his activities. He noted Sarullo has complained about Federal men watching his place of business off and on over the last six months."
On June 9, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is a close associate of both Charles LiCastri and his brother, Vincent LiCastri, who are active in the gambling rackets in Staten Island. [CI] noted while Sarullo is still handling shylock money, he has greatly reduced his activities [redacted]."
On July 13, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] was in Florida last month, looking up one of his customers who left New York without clearing up a shylock loan. [CI] stated this customer is known as [Redacted]. According to Sarullo, the customer when he saw him, almost passed out expecting a beating, but when told he had 24 hours to raise the amount of the loan, the customer immediately got the money together and paid him off the next day."
On September 11, 1972 Sarullo was interviewed for a second time and gave Agents a rundown of his family and employment history.
In October 1972 included in the FBI's list of 201 identified Gambino Family members.
On December 11, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has curtailed his loansharking activities [and] will now do business only with individuals he knows well or those who come highly recommended."
On February 22, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] who is employed by [redacted] is pushing shylock money for Vincent Sarullo. [Redacted] gets the money from Sarullo at 2 points, and puts it on the street at the normal 6 for 5 rate. CI said [Redacted] drives Sarullo to Brooklyn regularly on Friday nights or Saturday mornings, at which time Sarullo meets with wise guys in Brooklyn."
In October 1973 included in the FBI's list of 196 identified Gambino Family members.
On October 25, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] can be seen almost daily hanging outside the Club Trio on the corner of Olympia Blvd and Sane Lane [which] is only two blocks from Sarullo's home."
An article published in the Staten Island Advance on April 28, 1974 included Sarullo in a list of local LCN members.
In April 1975 an FBI spot check on Club Trio observed a vehicle registered to John Motola (26y).
In December 1975 included in the FBI's list of 192 identified Gambino Family members.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 195 identified Gambino Family members.
An FBI report compiled on May 11, 1977 noted: "According to sources, Sarullo is only involved in loansharking activities on a limited basis. Sarullo is said to do business only with individuals known personally by him or that are highly recommended. Sarullo is also reportedly running books on horse bets and other sporting events...Sarullo was selected as a target for development as a potential Top Echelon Informant in a case opened in 6/1972. Sarullo was interviewed several times and although he spoke freely about his own background, he denied any direct knowledge of LCN and refused to discuss any specifics. (Note: Sarullo maintained a warm, friendly attitude towards FBI Agents)."
In November 1980 Vincent Sarullo attended the wedding reception for Sicilian Mafia Member Giuseppe Bono in Manhattan. Many members from New York Families, as well as from Canada and Sicily, were present. During the reception Sarullo was photographed at a table with Gambino Soldiers (and Traina crew members) Louis Giardina, Charles LiCastri, Joseph Marino as well as Gambino Soldier Anthony 'Tony Lee' Guerrieri and Gambino Associate Salvatore Reale. (The photograph and subsequent identifications were posted on The Black Hand Forum.)
Around 1983 sold Club Trio and retired.
He is included in the April 1988 Senate Chart of Gambino Family membership.
In January 8, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised [Redacted], who owed Vincent Sarullo $3,000 in loanshark money, skipped to Florida and Sarullo has been canvassing his friends to see who is heading to Florida so they can collect the debt from [Redacted]. He stated that Sarullo will always give his customers an extension of time if he feels they deserve it, but always sees red when somebody tried to beat him out of his money."
On May 25, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has been very quiet in recent months and has said he will lay low for awhile until the IRS has discontinued the investigation into his activities. He noted Sarullo has complained about Federal men watching his place of business off and on over the last six months."
On June 9, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] is a close associate of both Charles LiCastri and his brother, Vincent LiCastri, who are active in the gambling rackets in Staten Island. [CI] noted while Sarullo is still handling shylock money, he has greatly reduced his activities [redacted]."
On July 13, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] was in Florida last month, looking up one of his customers who left New York without clearing up a shylock loan. [CI] stated this customer is known as [Redacted]. According to Sarullo, the customer when he saw him, almost passed out expecting a beating, but when told he had 24 hours to raise the amount of the loan, the customer immediately got the money together and paid him off the next day."
On September 11, 1972 Sarullo was interviewed for a second time and gave Agents a rundown of his family and employment history.
In October 1972 included in the FBI's list of 201 identified Gambino Family members.
On December 11, 1972 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] has curtailed his loansharking activities [and] will now do business only with individuals he knows well or those who come highly recommended."
On February 22, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[Redacted] who is employed by [redacted] is pushing shylock money for Vincent Sarullo. [Redacted] gets the money from Sarullo at 2 points, and puts it on the street at the normal 6 for 5 rate. CI said [Redacted] drives Sarullo to Brooklyn regularly on Friday nights or Saturday mornings, at which time Sarullo meets with wise guys in Brooklyn."
In October 1973 included in the FBI's list of 196 identified Gambino Family members.
On October 25, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[Sarullo] can be seen almost daily hanging outside the Club Trio on the corner of Olympia Blvd and Sane Lane [which] is only two blocks from Sarullo's home."
An article published in the Staten Island Advance on April 28, 1974 included Sarullo in a list of local LCN members.
In April 1975 an FBI spot check on Club Trio observed a vehicle registered to John Motola (26y).
In December 1975 included in the FBI's list of 192 identified Gambino Family members.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 195 identified Gambino Family members.
An FBI report compiled on May 11, 1977 noted: "According to sources, Sarullo is only involved in loansharking activities on a limited basis. Sarullo is said to do business only with individuals known personally by him or that are highly recommended. Sarullo is also reportedly running books on horse bets and other sporting events...Sarullo was selected as a target for development as a potential Top Echelon Informant in a case opened in 6/1972. Sarullo was interviewed several times and although he spoke freely about his own background, he denied any direct knowledge of LCN and refused to discuss any specifics. (Note: Sarullo maintained a warm, friendly attitude towards FBI Agents)."
In November 1980 Vincent Sarullo attended the wedding reception for Sicilian Mafia Member Giuseppe Bono in Manhattan. Many members from New York Families, as well as from Canada and Sicily, were present. During the reception Sarullo was photographed at a table with Gambino Soldiers (and Traina crew members) Louis Giardina, Charles LiCastri, Joseph Marino as well as Gambino Soldier Anthony 'Tony Lee' Guerrieri and Gambino Associate Salvatore Reale. (The photograph and subsequent identifications were posted on The Black Hand Forum.)
Around 1983 sold Club Trio and retired.
He is included in the April 1988 Senate Chart of Gambino Family membership.
 |
| A. Capo (Sept. 1989) |
In December 1989 Anthony Capo was inducted into the DeCavalcante Family. After the ceremony Capo was told that introductions to members of other Families would be put off for awhile due to his recent involvement in a murder. Capo later testified: "[Because] of the scrutiny I was under of law enforcement for the Fred Weiss homicide, they decided I could only meet Jimmy Serillo [Sarullo], who's a Soldier in the Gambino Family, God father to my wife, or Johnny Pate, the captain of the Colombo Family. We were going to keep it under wraps for awhile, six months at least."
 |
| M. Traina Court Exhibit |
By 1990 members under Mario Traina included Joseph Giardina Jr., Louis Giardina, Salvatore Giardina, Charles LiCastri, Vincent LiCastri, Samuel Mannino, Joseph Marino and Vincent Sarullo.
By the early 1990s moved to Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island.
In June 1993 included in the FBI's list of 209 identified Gambino Family members.
A Govt chart compiled in May 2000 indicates that at least a couple of Traina's crew members (the Giardina brothers) had since transferred to the Arcuri / Franco regime. Sarullo was not included in the chart.
He died March 29, 2002 at his Fort Wadsworth residence and was waked at John Vincent Scalia Home for Funerals in Eltingville, SI.
By the early 1990s moved to Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island.
In June 1993 included in the FBI's list of 209 identified Gambino Family members.
A Govt chart compiled in May 2000 indicates that at least a couple of Traina's crew members (the Giardina brothers) had since transferred to the Arcuri / Franco regime. Sarullo was not included in the chart.
He died March 29, 2002 at his Fort Wadsworth residence and was waked at John Vincent Scalia Home for Funerals in Eltingville, SI.
