Administration:
1. Boss: Joseph Colombo (42y)
- Lawrence Gallo (38y)
- Charles 'Charlie Sidge' LoCicero (61y) (IP 2.65; USP Atlanta - FHD Manhattan)
- Rocco 'Rocky' Miraglia (39y)
- Anthony Peraino (50y)
- Joseph Peraino (39y)
- Modesto ‘Duke’ Santoro (53y)
- Michael Savino (57y)
- Gregory Scarpa (37y)
- Ralph ‘Whitey’ Tropiano (53y) (CT)
- Joseph ‘Joe Yak’ Yacovelli (37y)
3. Consigliere: Benedetto D’Alessandro (65y) (Appointed 7.65)
Captains:
- Ambrose Magliocco (64y)
- Antonio Magliocco (56y)
- Frank Melia (72y)
- Vincent ‘Little Jimmy’ Melia (49y)
- James 'Jimmy the Barber' Rubertone (63y)
- Paul D’Amico (51y)
- Vincent Mangano (59y)
- Carmelo 'Joe' Mutoli (53y)
- Giuseppe 'Pino' Tipa Jr. (54y)
- Salvatore John Fontana (70y)
- Benjamin ‘Benny Sidge’ LoCicero (32y)
- Vincent ‘Jimmy’ Muce (45y)
- John Scimone (53y)
- Alphonse 'Funzi' D'Ambrosio (41y)
- Leonard Dello (38y)
- Aniello ‘Allie Lamont’ Giannattasio (56y)
- Vincent ‘Vinny Sicilian’ Gugliaro (37y)
- Salvatore ‘Sally Westo’ Imperiale (53y)
- Lawrence ‘Old Man Lorenzo’ Lampasi (78y)
- Lawrence Lampasi (40y)
- George Tropiano (50y)
- Salvatore Badalamenti (60y) (Transferred from Colombo Crew 7.65)
- Joseph ‘Little Joey’ Brancato (48y)
- Fred ‘No Nose’ DeLucia (36y)
- Nicolo Failla (79y) (Died 9.65)
- Rosario ‘Black Sam’ Nastasa (53y)
- Dominick ‘Mimi’ Scialo (38y)
- Joseph ‘Jo Jo’ Vitacco (38y) (IP; NYS)
- Salvatore Cannella (80y)
- John D’Amico (74y)
- Andrew Lombardino (61y)
- Paul Lombardino (61y)
- Rosario Lombardino (40y)
- Salvatore Lombardino Sr. (74y)
- Salvatore ‘Turi’ Lombardino Jr. (34y)
- Arturo ‘Art Price’ Misuraca (65y) (FL)
- Angelo Speciale (56y)
- Frank ‘Frankie the Sheik’ Musacchio (50y)
- Frank Profaci (58y)
- Salvatore J. Profaci (29y)
- Salvatore S. Profaci (30y)
- Joseph 'Fat Richie' Zorzi (37y)
- Fred Clemenza (42y)
- James ‘Jimmy Brown’ Clemenza (54y)
- Anthony Crivello (53y)
- Charles ‘Lolly’ DePierro (37y)
- Patsy Guariglia (50y) (Died 1.65)
- Charles ‘Charlie Moose’ Panarella (43y)
- James ‘Jimmy Bats’ Cardello (60y)
- Thomas DiBella (60y) (Transferred from Colombo Crew 7.65)
- Anthony ‘Tony Long’ Ricciardi (54y)
- Anthony ‘Tony Ski’ Scianna (35y) (IP; NYS 5.65)
- James ‘Jimmy Ski’ Scianna (49y)
- FNU Columbo (2) (c. 65y)
- Antonio ‘Tony Lap’ LaPonzina (47y)
- Ernest ‘Ernie Lap’ LaPonzina (48y)
- Ralph LaPonzina (55y) (FL)
- Frank 'Gandy' LoCicero (38y)
Total: 104
- 114 members upon Colombo’s election
- Nicholas Bianco (33y) (Transferred to Colombo Family 9.22.65)
Notes
- Salvatore Badalamenti, Thomas DiBella and Ambrose Magliocco were former captains who had been demoted shortly after Colombo's appointment to Boss. Colombo made Vincent Aloi captain of a new crew and also maintained his own decina, comprised of his former crew members as well as several individuals involved in the Gallo conflict. Some of those direct with Colombo would eventually be shifted to other crews or promoted to head their own.
- Scarpa made several misidentifications that were cleared up in the following years. These included:
1. Charles Clemenza - Later confirmed reference to Fred Clemenza.
2. Joseph Giammarino - Later confirmed reference to Joseph Brancato.
Edit1: Moved Sebastiano D'Agati to Possibles.