 |
| 1970 |
Salvatore 'Toto' Mirabile was a member of the Bonanno Family active in Brooklyn.
Son John aka 'Johnny Boy' is a Bonanno Soldier inducted in the early 1990s.
Mirabile was related by marriage to at least three LCN members:
Son John aka 'Johnny Boy' is a Bonanno Soldier inducted in the early 1990s.
Mirabile was related by marriage to at least three LCN members:
- Older sister Josephine married a brother of John 'Johnny Pesce' Chiarello (1913-1981), a Gambino Soldier. (Future Gambino Captain Vincent 'Jimmy the Blond' Corrao witnessed their marriage.)
- Older sister Bessie married Joseph Marsala (1912-1969), a possible Gambino Member and father of future Gambino Captain Pasquale 'Patsy' Marsala (1940-2021). (The elder Marsala is believed to have been reporting to Vincent Corrao at the time of his death.)
- Mirabile himself married Rose D'Agostino, a cousin of Gambino Soldier Louis 'Fat Lou' D'Agostino (1908-1991). D'Agostino was a stepbrother of Giuseppe Traina, a long-time influence in that Family who, like Mirabile's mother Elizabeth Buttacavoli, hailed from Belmonte Mezzagno in Palermo.
At the time of birth the family were residing at 2915 Bay 50th St in Brooklyn's Gravesend section. Salvatore remained in that neighborhood for most of his life.
By the following year they had moved about a block south at 2517 W 17th St.
He spent approximately a year and a half at New Utrecht High School at 16th Ave and 79th St in Bensonhurst.
On December 2, 1934 sister Josephine (22y) married Joseph Chiarello (26y) in Brooklyn. The marriage was witnessed by Vincent Corrao and his wife, Jennie Perino. (Chiarello, also from Palermo, was a brother of Future Gambino Soldier John 'Johnny Pesce' Chiarello. Johnny Pesce and Corrao started out in the same Gambino crew, and Chiarello later reported to Corrao upon the latter's promotion to Captain. Corrao's wife Jennie was a sister of Vincent 'Yumpie' Perino, another Gambino Soldier who was stabbed to death by his girlfriend in 1959.)
On October 18, 1936 sister Bessie (26y) and Joseph Marsala (24y) married in Brooklyn. (Marsala, from Montallegro in Agrigento, was a suspected Gambino Member in the same crew as Chiarello, Corrao and Perino. Son Pasquale aka Patsy Marsala was identified as a Gambino Captain around 2010.)
Given his many Gambino connections, it's possible Mirabile started out as an associate of that Family.
On November 12, 1939 he was arrested by the NYPD in Brooklyn on two counts of assault 3rd degree. Around June 20, 1940 convicted and sentenced to twenty days imprisonment at Rikers Island.
By Fall 1940 employed with in-law Charles Segreto at 148 E 170th St.
On January 23, 1942 inducted into US Army at Camp Upton, New York.
On July 31, 1942 convicted of desertion by US Army general court-martial.
On March 8, 1944 restored to active duty.
On September 19, 1945 honorably discharged due to demobilization. At the time served as Technician fifth grade at Papago Park, Arizona.
On January 10, 1948 married Rosalie D'Agostino in Brooklyn. The bride was a cousin to Gambino Soldier Louis 'Fat Lou' D'Agostino.
By April 1950 the Mirabiles resided at 140 Bay 40th St in Gravesend. Salvatore listed his occupation as a lather (building construction).
On February 28, 1953 arrested by NYPD Brooklyn on gambling (dice) charge.
By late 1953 believed operated a furniture store at 23rd Ave and 86th St.
On January 1, 1954, at approximately 4:00 AM, Mirabile was arrested on a disorderly conduct charge. Mirabile and others were celebrating the New Year in Bath Beach when the bartender was arrested. Mirabile, with others, followed the officers to their station house and began hurling insults. On January 2, 1954 appeared before Weekend Court Magistrate Anthony J. Maglio. The New York Daily News reported: "'It seems to me,' observed [Maglio], after he had heard the story, 'that all this is kind of silly. The police tell me, Mr. Mirabile, that you are a substantial businessman of this community, that you run a furniture store over at 86th St. and 23rd Ave. How come all this nonsense?' 'Your Honor', replied Sal earnestly, 'I don't really get it myself. We were having a party and I was drinking some and, of course, I probably was a little hot when the party was broken up. But calling the police names is something I can't understand. Why, I'm friendly with all the police of this precinct. They're my pals'." Given suspended sentence.
By 1958 Mirabile was a formally inducted member of the Bonanno Family believed to be reporting to John Tartamella.
 |
| J. Tartamella (1960) |
In addition to serving as the Family's Consigliere, Tartamella retained a crew of Soldiers that included Salvatore Mirabile, Benjamin 'Coney Island Benny' Valvo and Matteo 'Matty' Valvo.
Possible crew members included Soldier Mario 'Dr. Tag' Tagliagambe.
A second marriage record exists for Mirabile and Catherine D'Agostino dated April 25, 1958. Witnesses listed as Palermitano Anthony Severino (1893-1975) and Mirabile's sister Catherine 'Kay' Segreto.
Mirabile worked as checker and later expediter with an excavation company owned by his wife's brothers in Whitestone, Queens.
By 1961 resided at 8621 23rd Ave. Salvatore was employed as manager of Knapp Street Lobster Corporation at 2771 Knapp St in Sheepshead Bay.
Chartered in 1953, the original owners were bought out by Bonanno Soldier Matteo Valvo and an Unsub in the Fall of 1955. In October 1959 Valvo resigned and Gus Trombetta (1912-1985) took over as Director. By the 1960s the officers were replaced by Mirabile's wife Rose, his brother-in-law Louis Segreto and Joseph Evola. (Trombetta's parents were from Salerno, Campania and Bari, Puglia. Joseph Evola was younger brother to Natale 'Joe Diamond' Evola, a former Bonanno Captain serving Federal time for narcotics. Some or all of the crew reporting direct to John Tartamella may have been under Evola prior to the latter's incarceration.)
In July 1961 Matteo Valvo and his wife served as the baptismal godparents for Salvatore's son John.
By 1962 listed employment with All Boro Lathing Corporation headquartered in Brooklyn.
His illegitimate interests included a loansharking operation.
Around the middle of that year John Tartamella suffered a stroke. His Soldiers were given to newly appointed Captain Matteo Valvo.
Possible crew members included Soldier Mario 'Dr. Tag' Tagliagambe.
A second marriage record exists for Mirabile and Catherine D'Agostino dated April 25, 1958. Witnesses listed as Palermitano Anthony Severino (1893-1975) and Mirabile's sister Catherine 'Kay' Segreto.
Mirabile worked as checker and later expediter with an excavation company owned by his wife's brothers in Whitestone, Queens.
By 1961 resided at 8621 23rd Ave. Salvatore was employed as manager of Knapp Street Lobster Corporation at 2771 Knapp St in Sheepshead Bay.
Chartered in 1953, the original owners were bought out by Bonanno Soldier Matteo Valvo and an Unsub in the Fall of 1955. In October 1959 Valvo resigned and Gus Trombetta (1912-1985) took over as Director. By the 1960s the officers were replaced by Mirabile's wife Rose, his brother-in-law Louis Segreto and Joseph Evola. (Trombetta's parents were from Salerno, Campania and Bari, Puglia. Joseph Evola was younger brother to Natale 'Joe Diamond' Evola, a former Bonanno Captain serving Federal time for narcotics. Some or all of the crew reporting direct to John Tartamella may have been under Evola prior to the latter's incarceration.)
In July 1961 Matteo Valvo and his wife served as the baptismal godparents for Salvatore's son John.
By 1962 listed employment with All Boro Lathing Corporation headquartered in Brooklyn.
His illegitimate interests included a loansharking operation.
Around the middle of that year John Tartamella suffered a stroke. His Soldiers were given to newly appointed Captain Matteo Valvo.
 |
| M. Valvo (1964) |
Made members of Valvo's crew included Salvatore Mirabile and Matteo's younger brother Benjamin Valvo.
Possible members included Dr. Mario Tagliagambe.
In 1962 listed employment with various lathing companies in Brooklyn.
On March 20, 1963 an FBI CI reported on Matteo Valvo. The CI noted that Valvo was planning a dinner party for Bonanno Acting Boss John 'Johnny Burns' Morale at Villa Joe's Restaurant on West 15th St. The CI stated that Valvo was seeking to 'ingratiate himself' with Morale, and estimated 'six to ten wise guys' and 'their wives or girlfriends' would be present. The CI named Benny Valvo and another Bonanno Soldier, whose name was redacted, as among those he expected to attend. (The redacted individual may have been Salvatore Mirabile. A week later the informant noted that the dinner was canceled on account of Valvo's wife falling ill.)
Possible members included Dr. Mario Tagliagambe.
In 1962 listed employment with various lathing companies in Brooklyn.
On March 20, 1963 an FBI CI reported on Matteo Valvo. The CI noted that Valvo was planning a dinner party for Bonanno Acting Boss John 'Johnny Burns' Morale at Villa Joe's Restaurant on West 15th St. The CI stated that Valvo was seeking to 'ingratiate himself' with Morale, and estimated 'six to ten wise guys' and 'their wives or girlfriends' would be present. The CI named Benny Valvo and another Bonanno Soldier, whose name was redacted, as among those he expected to attend. (The redacted individual may have been Salvatore Mirabile. A week later the informant noted that the dinner was canceled on account of Valvo's wife falling ill.)
 |
| C. Lombardozzi |
On September 3, 1964 Mirabile witnessed the marriage of Gambino Captain Carmine Lombardozzi to Arlene Muro (24y) in Yonkers. The bride's father, Sabato 'Sammy Mintz' Muro, was a Gambino Soldier in Lombardozzi's crew. (Lombardozzi's involvement with the daughter of one of his own men in part led to a demotion that same year.)
On August 17, 1965, at 4:30 AM, an Unspecified Male was assaulted by Mirabile and another man at 2279 86th St in Gravesend. One week later Mirabile was arrested on Bath Avenue by the 62nd Precinct and charged with felonious assault. Arrest Report stated: "While acting in concert with one [Redacted] also arrested did strike compl. about the head with a broom stick causing him to receive 7 stitches on the head and 3 on the arm." (The disposition of this case is not available.)
On February 14, 1966 one of the FBI's sources in the Bonanno Family was extensively questioned: "...[CI] identified another individual who is a 'button guy' in La Cosa Nostra, and formerly with Joseph Bonanno, but is presently allied with [Boss Gaspare] DiGregorio as a person known only to [CI] as 'Toddo'. This individual's first name is Salvatore and he is under Matty Valvo, a former Joseph Bonanno Caporegima. 'Toddo' was Carmine Lombardozzi's best man at his recent wedding. [CI] advised that Matty Valvo and his people hang out at the Knapp Lobster Inn located on Knapp St in the Sheepshead Bay section of Brooklyn."
On April 11, 1966 Mirabile was interviewed by FBI for the first time: "He is the manager of the Knapp Street Lobster Corporation [owned by his wife and] her partner, Louis Segreto...[He] advised that he was the best man at the wedding of Carmine Lombardozzi in Yonkers, a few months ago. He was asked by Lombardozzi, a friend for many years, to be his best man. Mirabile advised that the wedding was a small affair and he refused to discuss the facts surrounding the wedding. He advised that Carmine Lombardozzi is a frequent visitor at [Knapp Street]. Mirabile also advised that Matty Valvo and his brother, Benny Valvo, are also frequent visitors...Mirabile is the godfather of Benny Valvo's [redacted]. Matty Valvo and his wife, Mary, are godparents of his [son John]. Mirabile denied any knowledge of La Cosa Nostra and affiliation with such a group. He also declined to discuss the activities of any of his associates."
On April 27, 1966 Gambino Soldier Louis 'Fat Lou' D'Agostino was interviewed by the FBI: "...He is presently working for D'Agostino Excavators Inc., 77-11 51st Ave, Elmhurst, Queens [owned by] his cousins. The D'Agostino brothers have a sister, Rosalie, who is married to Salvatore Mirabile...He stated that he is not a member of La Cosa Nostra, nor does he know anyone who is and his knowledge of it is limited to what he has read in the newspapers."
On May 12-13, 1966 among fifteen who appeared before a Southern District of New York Federal Grand Jury investigating the Bonanno Family. Those who appeared in addition to Mirabile included Boss Gaspare DiGregorio and Captains Michael 'Mikey Pip' Consolo, Joseph DiFilippi, Salvatore 'Sally Fruits' Ferrugia and Sereno 'Bob' Tartamella. All invoked the Fifth Amendment and were ordered to return at a later date.
In August 1966 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he knows Salvatore Mirabile as a member of LCN. [CI] did not know who is Mirabile's captain, however, [CI] assumed that Mirabile is a member of the Carlo Gambino Family of LCN. [CI] advised that Mirabile is engaged in shylocking, however, [CI] did not know any of the details concerning Mirabile's shylocking."
On December 14, 1966 Mirabile was interviewed for a second time by the FBI: "...Mirabile claimed that he has not seen Carmine Lombardozzi for over a year. In regard to his witnessing of Lombardozzi's marriage to Arlene Muro, Mirabile said that he and his wife did this simply as a favor and based on their friendship. Mirabile commented he knew Arlene's father, Sabato Muro; however, he had no additional comments to make on Muro or the wedding. Mirabile denied any knowledge of La Cosa Nostra except what he has read in the newspapers. He advised that it is true he has met and known several of the persons referred to as LCN members whose names have appeared in the newspapers, however, he is not a member of LCN nor does he have any knowledge of any of his friends being members of such a group. Mirabile added that he is the owner of the apartment building located at 8621 23rd Avenue, Brooklyn, where he now resides."
On November 18, 1967 he was again interviewed: "...Mirabile refused to comment any further regarding the Knapp Street Lobster Corporation. At this time Salvatore Mirabile is unemployed. He had been collecting unemployment compensation from New York State for about three or four months during the past year. His wife is a part-time dress operator and her income contributes to the support of their family. Mirabile advised his main source of income comes from a $10,000 loan which his wife obtained in her own name. He and his wife took $3,000 of this loan and have been using this amount, coupled with his wife's income, to support his family. Mirabile refused to identify the bank where his wife obtained this loan. He refused to state what was used as collateral to obtain this loan. He refused to offer any additional information concerning his source of income. He stated he did not own any type of business or property. When asked specifically about his ownership of the apartment building in which he resided, Mirabile stated that he did not own it nor has he ever owned it. Mirabile stated that he has never borrowed money from any person and any loans he obtained were from banks. He denied owing or paying Carmine Lombardozzi $3,000, and stated Lombardozzi had no financial interest and did not receive any money from [Knapp Street]."
By 1968 Mirabile's crew leader Matteo Valvo had been demoted and both were reporting to Captain Michael Sabella.
On August 17, 1965, at 4:30 AM, an Unspecified Male was assaulted by Mirabile and another man at 2279 86th St in Gravesend. One week later Mirabile was arrested on Bath Avenue by the 62nd Precinct and charged with felonious assault. Arrest Report stated: "While acting in concert with one [Redacted] also arrested did strike compl. about the head with a broom stick causing him to receive 7 stitches on the head and 3 on the arm." (The disposition of this case is not available.)
On February 14, 1966 one of the FBI's sources in the Bonanno Family was extensively questioned: "...[CI] identified another individual who is a 'button guy' in La Cosa Nostra, and formerly with Joseph Bonanno, but is presently allied with [Boss Gaspare] DiGregorio as a person known only to [CI] as 'Toddo'. This individual's first name is Salvatore and he is under Matty Valvo, a former Joseph Bonanno Caporegima. 'Toddo' was Carmine Lombardozzi's best man at his recent wedding. [CI] advised that Matty Valvo and his people hang out at the Knapp Lobster Inn located on Knapp St in the Sheepshead Bay section of Brooklyn."
On April 11, 1966 Mirabile was interviewed by FBI for the first time: "He is the manager of the Knapp Street Lobster Corporation [owned by his wife and] her partner, Louis Segreto...[He] advised that he was the best man at the wedding of Carmine Lombardozzi in Yonkers, a few months ago. He was asked by Lombardozzi, a friend for many years, to be his best man. Mirabile advised that the wedding was a small affair and he refused to discuss the facts surrounding the wedding. He advised that Carmine Lombardozzi is a frequent visitor at [Knapp Street]. Mirabile also advised that Matty Valvo and his brother, Benny Valvo, are also frequent visitors...Mirabile is the godfather of Benny Valvo's [redacted]. Matty Valvo and his wife, Mary, are godparents of his [son John]. Mirabile denied any knowledge of La Cosa Nostra and affiliation with such a group. He also declined to discuss the activities of any of his associates."
On April 27, 1966 Gambino Soldier Louis 'Fat Lou' D'Agostino was interviewed by the FBI: "...He is presently working for D'Agostino Excavators Inc., 77-11 51st Ave, Elmhurst, Queens [owned by] his cousins. The D'Agostino brothers have a sister, Rosalie, who is married to Salvatore Mirabile...He stated that he is not a member of La Cosa Nostra, nor does he know anyone who is and his knowledge of it is limited to what he has read in the newspapers."
On May 12-13, 1966 among fifteen who appeared before a Southern District of New York Federal Grand Jury investigating the Bonanno Family. Those who appeared in addition to Mirabile included Boss Gaspare DiGregorio and Captains Michael 'Mikey Pip' Consolo, Joseph DiFilippi, Salvatore 'Sally Fruits' Ferrugia and Sereno 'Bob' Tartamella. All invoked the Fifth Amendment and were ordered to return at a later date.
In August 1966 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that he knows Salvatore Mirabile as a member of LCN. [CI] did not know who is Mirabile's captain, however, [CI] assumed that Mirabile is a member of the Carlo Gambino Family of LCN. [CI] advised that Mirabile is engaged in shylocking, however, [CI] did not know any of the details concerning Mirabile's shylocking."
On December 14, 1966 Mirabile was interviewed for a second time by the FBI: "...Mirabile claimed that he has not seen Carmine Lombardozzi for over a year. In regard to his witnessing of Lombardozzi's marriage to Arlene Muro, Mirabile said that he and his wife did this simply as a favor and based on their friendship. Mirabile commented he knew Arlene's father, Sabato Muro; however, he had no additional comments to make on Muro or the wedding. Mirabile denied any knowledge of La Cosa Nostra except what he has read in the newspapers. He advised that it is true he has met and known several of the persons referred to as LCN members whose names have appeared in the newspapers, however, he is not a member of LCN nor does he have any knowledge of any of his friends being members of such a group. Mirabile added that he is the owner of the apartment building located at 8621 23rd Avenue, Brooklyn, where he now resides."
On November 18, 1967 he was again interviewed: "...Mirabile refused to comment any further regarding the Knapp Street Lobster Corporation. At this time Salvatore Mirabile is unemployed. He had been collecting unemployment compensation from New York State for about three or four months during the past year. His wife is a part-time dress operator and her income contributes to the support of their family. Mirabile advised his main source of income comes from a $10,000 loan which his wife obtained in her own name. He and his wife took $3,000 of this loan and have been using this amount, coupled with his wife's income, to support his family. Mirabile refused to identify the bank where his wife obtained this loan. He refused to state what was used as collateral to obtain this loan. He refused to offer any additional information concerning his source of income. He stated he did not own any type of business or property. When asked specifically about his ownership of the apartment building in which he resided, Mirabile stated that he did not own it nor has he ever owned it. Mirabile stated that he has never borrowed money from any person and any loans he obtained were from banks. He denied owing or paying Carmine Lombardozzi $3,000, and stated Lombardozzi had no financial interest and did not receive any money from [Knapp Street]."
By 1968 Mirabile's crew leader Matteo Valvo had been demoted and both were reporting to Captain Michael Sabella.
 |
| M. Sabella (1969) |
As of 1968 made members of Sabella's crew included Epifanio 'Frank Fani' D'Angelo, William 'Willie the Tilemaker' Dara, Salvatore Mirabile, Anthony 'Bull' Spadaro and Matteo Valvo.
Possible crew members included Antonino 'Nino' Adamo, Alfonso 'Big Al' DeMarinis and Benjamin Valvo.
In March 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Toddo Mirabile is an associate of Carmine Lombardozzi and handles shylock money for Lombardozzi. [CI] advised the Knapp Street Lobster House with which Mirabile is associated, is now closed because of Mirabile's lack of money to keep it going."
On September 14, 1968 the children of Bonanno Boss Paul Sciacca and Bonanno Underboss Frank 'Frankie T.' Mari were married. The reception was held at Woodbury Country Club in Long Island. Attendees included Colombo Boss Joseph Colombo, Bonanno Captain Philip 'Rusty' Rastelli, Bonanno Soldiers Salvatore Mirabile and Rosario 'Sally Burns' Morale as well as Proposed Bonanno Associate Joseph Mastrocola.
In September 1968 included in the FBI's list of 88 identified Bonanno Family members.
In September 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Toddo Mirabile is a Soldier in the Paul Sciacca Family of LCN and his Capodecina is Mike Sabella. [CI] advised Mirabile is not active and does not have any type of action. He described Mirabile as being 'flat on his heels' and Mirabile is handling small amounts of 'swag' whenever he can get any of it. [CI] advised that Mirabile is not aggressive and has such a reputation and, therefore, has never amounted to much."
On October 15, 1968 interviewed by FBI: "Mirabile advised he is unemployed and depends upon his wife's income to sustain his family. He refused to enter into discussion about his activities."
Around that time Michael Sabella was demoted to Soldier and assigned to Philip Rastelli.
Frank D'Angelo is believed to have been promoted to Captain over some or all of the former Sabella crew.
By September 1969 Mirabile resided in basement apartment of the building at 2517 W 17th St.
That month an FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Deauville Caterers, Inc., 3939 Shore Parkway, Brooklyn, is frequented by the following individuals: Salvatore Mirabile, [Redacted], Salvatore Peritore, Sabato Muro, Carmine Lombardozzi, Joseph Livoti." Head of corporation identified as Edward Ronis (55y). (Salvatore 'Sammy' Peritore was a Colombo Soldier. Joseph 'Minx' Livoti was a long-time Colombo Associate.)
On October 8, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that the Esplanade Cafe, the 18th Avenue Civic Association and several adjoining homes on West 17th Avenue were formerly owned by Joseph Marsala, Sr., who was related to Toddo Mirabile by marriage. According to [CI], Marsala recently died and Toddo did not attend the funeral. For this and other reasons, there were hard feelings between the Marsala family and Mirabile. [CI] stated somehow Toddo had taken over control of these properties and was making the present tenants move out. [CI] did not know if Toddo Mirabile was employed at present time."
Eight days later Mirabile's wife told Agents that her husband was working for a construction and demolition company in Manhattan.
In November 1969 included in the FBI's list of 73 identified Bonanno Family members.
On June 16, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Salvatore Mirabile is not employed steadily and his only income is from gambling activity [in Brooklyn]. [CI] has also advised that Mirabile has been out of the area of New York City lately and is believed to be located somewhere in upper New York State."
On November 17, 1970 observed by FBI in discussion with two Unsubs inside Esplanade Cafe located on Bay 50th St and West 17th St in Gravesend.
On December 27, 1970 Mirabile and an Unsub were arrested by the 62nd Precinct on a charge of criminally possessing stolen property. Arrest Report noted: "While acting in concert with another also arrested did have in possession stolen property, to wit: Whiskey - metal lunch containers, valued over $250." The pair were picked up at a social club on West 17th St in Gravesend. Case subsequently dismissed.
On March 9, 1971 his wife was interviewed by the FBI: "Mrs. Mirabile advised that Salvatore Mirabile was not at home and she has no idea as to his whereabouts. She advised she does not expect him home until late at night if at all."
On August 10, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Salvatore Mirabile continues to frequent the Esplanade Cafe and apparently is unemployed."
On April 5, 1972 Mirabile and an Unsub (c. 50y) were observed by the FBI going to and from Mirabile's residence and the Esplanade.
Around August 1972 spent a month in Italy with his wife and son.
On October 4, 1972 approached for interview by FBI: "[Agent] contacted Salvatore Mirabile at his residence in Brooklyn. Mirabile advised contacting Agent that he would not talk to the FBI."
In October 1972 included in the FBI's list of 72 identified Bonanno Family members.
In October 1973 included in the FBI's list of 72 identified Bonanno Family members.
On December 12, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that in the past he knew Salvatore Mirabile, aka Toddo, had been active in LCN affairs to some extent, but in the past few years, he has had no contact with them. He further indicated that when Toddo was in contact with known LCN figures, he was considered a loser and was not on the inside."
On January 14, 1974 FBI CI reported: "[CI] indicated, as he had in the past, that Salvatore Mirabile is inactive in LCN affairs. He indicated the same as [other CI] in that Salvatore Mirabile had been a loser in the past and was on the outside regarding any LCN affairs. He indicated presently he is certain Mirabile is inactive in LCN affairs and has no indication of becoming involved with them."
On February 14, 1974 interviewed by FBI: "Mirabile was contacted at his residence. He was sociable in that he spoke friendly with the agents in such matters as the pleasures of his neighborhood, the weather, and other pleasantries, however, when pertinent inquiries were made regarding his present status in organized crime or in any business, he declined to make any comment. The interview was terminated after a few minutes when Mirabile indicated he actually had no intention of revealing anything about himself to agents of the FBI."
On March 28, 1975 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised Salvatore Mirabile is known to him as a ‘made guy’. [CI] states Mirabile used to [redacted] New York, and hangs out at the Esplanade Cafe. [CI] advised that Mirabile is an associate of [Redacted] who also hangs out at the club.”
In December 1975 included in the FBI's list of 66 identified Bonanno Family members.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 65 identified Bonanno Family members.
By the first half of 1977 Matteo Valvo had again been appointed a Captain.
Around that time he sponsored Frank Coppa and John Palazzolo for membership. The two were inducted, along with Baldassare Amato and Cesare Bonventre, in a ceremony presided over by Carmine Galante.
Possible crew members included Antonino 'Nino' Adamo, Alfonso 'Big Al' DeMarinis and Benjamin Valvo.
In March 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Toddo Mirabile is an associate of Carmine Lombardozzi and handles shylock money for Lombardozzi. [CI] advised the Knapp Street Lobster House with which Mirabile is associated, is now closed because of Mirabile's lack of money to keep it going."
On September 14, 1968 the children of Bonanno Boss Paul Sciacca and Bonanno Underboss Frank 'Frankie T.' Mari were married. The reception was held at Woodbury Country Club in Long Island. Attendees included Colombo Boss Joseph Colombo, Bonanno Captain Philip 'Rusty' Rastelli, Bonanno Soldiers Salvatore Mirabile and Rosario 'Sally Burns' Morale as well as Proposed Bonanno Associate Joseph Mastrocola.
In September 1968 included in the FBI's list of 88 identified Bonanno Family members.
In September 1968 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Toddo Mirabile is a Soldier in the Paul Sciacca Family of LCN and his Capodecina is Mike Sabella. [CI] advised Mirabile is not active and does not have any type of action. He described Mirabile as being 'flat on his heels' and Mirabile is handling small amounts of 'swag' whenever he can get any of it. [CI] advised that Mirabile is not aggressive and has such a reputation and, therefore, has never amounted to much."
On October 15, 1968 interviewed by FBI: "Mirabile advised he is unemployed and depends upon his wife's income to sustain his family. He refused to enter into discussion about his activities."
Around that time Michael Sabella was demoted to Soldier and assigned to Philip Rastelli.
Frank D'Angelo is believed to have been promoted to Captain over some or all of the former Sabella crew.
By September 1969 Mirabile resided in basement apartment of the building at 2517 W 17th St.
That month an FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Deauville Caterers, Inc., 3939 Shore Parkway, Brooklyn, is frequented by the following individuals: Salvatore Mirabile, [Redacted], Salvatore Peritore, Sabato Muro, Carmine Lombardozzi, Joseph Livoti." Head of corporation identified as Edward Ronis (55y). (Salvatore 'Sammy' Peritore was a Colombo Soldier. Joseph 'Minx' Livoti was a long-time Colombo Associate.)
On October 8, 1969 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that the Esplanade Cafe, the 18th Avenue Civic Association and several adjoining homes on West 17th Avenue were formerly owned by Joseph Marsala, Sr., who was related to Toddo Mirabile by marriage. According to [CI], Marsala recently died and Toddo did not attend the funeral. For this and other reasons, there were hard feelings between the Marsala family and Mirabile. [CI] stated somehow Toddo had taken over control of these properties and was making the present tenants move out. [CI] did not know if Toddo Mirabile was employed at present time."
Eight days later Mirabile's wife told Agents that her husband was working for a construction and demolition company in Manhattan.
In November 1969 included in the FBI's list of 73 identified Bonanno Family members.
On June 16, 1970 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Salvatore Mirabile is not employed steadily and his only income is from gambling activity [in Brooklyn]. [CI] has also advised that Mirabile has been out of the area of New York City lately and is believed to be located somewhere in upper New York State."
On November 17, 1970 observed by FBI in discussion with two Unsubs inside Esplanade Cafe located on Bay 50th St and West 17th St in Gravesend.
On December 27, 1970 Mirabile and an Unsub were arrested by the 62nd Precinct on a charge of criminally possessing stolen property. Arrest Report noted: "While acting in concert with another also arrested did have in possession stolen property, to wit: Whiskey - metal lunch containers, valued over $250." The pair were picked up at a social club on West 17th St in Gravesend. Case subsequently dismissed.
On March 9, 1971 his wife was interviewed by the FBI: "Mrs. Mirabile advised that Salvatore Mirabile was not at home and she has no idea as to his whereabouts. She advised she does not expect him home until late at night if at all."
On August 10, 1971 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that Salvatore Mirabile continues to frequent the Esplanade Cafe and apparently is unemployed."
On April 5, 1972 Mirabile and an Unsub (c. 50y) were observed by the FBI going to and from Mirabile's residence and the Esplanade.
Around August 1972 spent a month in Italy with his wife and son.
On October 4, 1972 approached for interview by FBI: "[Agent] contacted Salvatore Mirabile at his residence in Brooklyn. Mirabile advised contacting Agent that he would not talk to the FBI."
In October 1972 included in the FBI's list of 72 identified Bonanno Family members.
In October 1973 included in the FBI's list of 72 identified Bonanno Family members.
On December 12, 1973 FBI CI reported: "[CI] advised that in the past he knew Salvatore Mirabile, aka Toddo, had been active in LCN affairs to some extent, but in the past few years, he has had no contact with them. He further indicated that when Toddo was in contact with known LCN figures, he was considered a loser and was not on the inside."
On January 14, 1974 FBI CI reported: "[CI] indicated, as he had in the past, that Salvatore Mirabile is inactive in LCN affairs. He indicated the same as [other CI] in that Salvatore Mirabile had been a loser in the past and was on the outside regarding any LCN affairs. He indicated presently he is certain Mirabile is inactive in LCN affairs and has no indication of becoming involved with them."
On February 14, 1974 interviewed by FBI: "Mirabile was contacted at his residence. He was sociable in that he spoke friendly with the agents in such matters as the pleasures of his neighborhood, the weather, and other pleasantries, however, when pertinent inquiries were made regarding his present status in organized crime or in any business, he declined to make any comment. The interview was terminated after a few minutes when Mirabile indicated he actually had no intention of revealing anything about himself to agents of the FBI."
On March 28, 1975 FBI CI reported: “[CI] advised Salvatore Mirabile is known to him as a ‘made guy’. [CI] states Mirabile used to [redacted] New York, and hangs out at the Esplanade Cafe. [CI] advised that Mirabile is an associate of [Redacted] who also hangs out at the club.”
In December 1975 included in the FBI's list of 66 identified Bonanno Family members.
In January 1977 included in the FBI's list of 65 identified Bonanno Family members.
By the first half of 1977 Matteo Valvo had again been appointed a Captain.
Around that time he sponsored Frank Coppa and John Palazzolo for membership. The two were inducted, along with Baldassare Amato and Cesare Bonventre, in a ceremony presided over by Carmine Galante.
 |
| F. Coppa (L) and M. Valvo (R) at Toyland Social Club in Lower Manhattan (Dec. 3, 1977) |
Frank Coppa had been an on-record Associate of Matteo's brother Benny Valvo since the early 1970s, and shortly after his induction he was named Acting Captain of the crew. After he became the Bonanno Family's first cooperating witness in the early 2000s, he testified about borrowing approximately one to two million dollars from various organized crime figures over the years: "[Shylocks included] Benny Valvo, Matty Valvo, [Gene] the Hat, Joe Lane, Tota, Nicky Black." (Nicky Black and Joe Lane were Colombo Members Nicholas Grancio and Joseph Gentile, inducted in 1977 and 1983 respectively. 'Tota' may be identical with Mirabile, a fellow Valvo crew member, or it could be referring to Former Genovese Captain Generoso 'Toto' Del Duca, who died in 1964. Members of the Valvo crew were known to have associated with Generoso's son, Genovese Soldier John aka 'Johnny Del'.)
By 1978 made members of Valvo's crew included Frank Coppa, Frank Lino, Paul 'Whitey' LNU, Salvatore Mirabile, John Palazzolo, Vito 'Wally' Palazzolo (ph) and Benjamin Valvo. (Paul Whitey LNU may have been a relative of deceased Gambino Soldier Paul 'Whitey' SanFilippo.)
Associates of interest included Ernest 'Kippy' Filocomo, Ronald 'Monkey Man' Filocomo, Robert 'Bobby' Lino and Salvatore 'Sally Bagels' Nunziato. (Lino was inducted in 1985. Nunziato was murdered in 1994.)
In September 1978 Acting Captain Frank Coppa was seriously injured in a car bombing outside his Staten Island restaurant. Suffering from burns to his face and shrapnel wounds to the legs and arms, Coppa was taken to St. Vincent's Hospital for treatment. Frank Lino was made the new Acting Captain. (The Family immediately began investigating the bombing and zeroed in on Anthony Coglitore, who had previously been ripped off by Coppa in a stock deal. Three months later a joint Bonanno-Gambino hit team shot and wounded Coglitore in his driveway. Coppa later testified that the attempt on his life may have instead been orchestrated by Gerard 'Jerry' Papa, a Genovese Soldier murdered in 1980.)
The following month an FBI CI noted that Valvo, a 'low key guy and rarely seen', had 'approximately five individuals in his crew'.
In June 1979 included in the FBI's list of 123 identified Bonanno Family members.
The following month Bonanno Acting Boss Carmine 'Lilo' Galante was shot to death on orders of the imprisoned Philip Rastelli.
A large scale reorganization of the Family took place in the wake of Galante's death. Matteo Valvo and several other Captains were demoted and replaced by members loyal to Rastelli.
By 1978 made members of Valvo's crew included Frank Coppa, Frank Lino, Paul 'Whitey' LNU, Salvatore Mirabile, John Palazzolo, Vito 'Wally' Palazzolo (ph) and Benjamin Valvo. (Paul Whitey LNU may have been a relative of deceased Gambino Soldier Paul 'Whitey' SanFilippo.)
Associates of interest included Ernest 'Kippy' Filocomo, Ronald 'Monkey Man' Filocomo, Robert 'Bobby' Lino and Salvatore 'Sally Bagels' Nunziato. (Lino was inducted in 1985. Nunziato was murdered in 1994.)
In September 1978 Acting Captain Frank Coppa was seriously injured in a car bombing outside his Staten Island restaurant. Suffering from burns to his face and shrapnel wounds to the legs and arms, Coppa was taken to St. Vincent's Hospital for treatment. Frank Lino was made the new Acting Captain. (The Family immediately began investigating the bombing and zeroed in on Anthony Coglitore, who had previously been ripped off by Coppa in a stock deal. Three months later a joint Bonanno-Gambino hit team shot and wounded Coglitore in his driveway. Coppa later testified that the attempt on his life may have instead been orchestrated by Gerard 'Jerry' Papa, a Genovese Soldier murdered in 1980.)
The following month an FBI CI noted that Valvo, a 'low key guy and rarely seen', had 'approximately five individuals in his crew'.
In June 1979 included in the FBI's list of 123 identified Bonanno Family members.
The following month Bonanno Acting Boss Carmine 'Lilo' Galante was shot to death on orders of the imprisoned Philip Rastelli.
A large scale reorganization of the Family took place in the wake of Galante's death. Matteo Valvo and several other Captains were demoted and replaced by members loyal to Rastelli.
 |
| C. Bonventre (1981) |
Mirabile was assigned to the newly promoted Cesare Bonventre, who had been present when Galante was murdered and is believed to have actively participated in the shooting.
By 1980 made members of Bonventre's crew included Baldassare 'Baldo' Amato, Louis 'Louie Ha-Ha' Attanasio, Frank Bonomo, John 'Johnny Green' Faraci, James Genna, Frank Lupo, Salvatore Mirabile and Robert 'Bobby Bad Heart' Perrette.
Possible crew members included Salvatore 'Sal Longo' Caccamise and Santo 'Toni' Giordano. (Caccamise may not have been made at the time. CW Salvatore Vitale later testified that he believed Giordano was Bonventre's Acting Captain circa May 1981.)
In January 1980 included in the FBI's list of 119 identified Bonanno Family members.
By Summer 1980 operated the One Eleven Social Club at West 17th and Bay 50th Sts in Gravesend.
On September 11, 1980 FBI surveillance conducted on Caffe Roma in Bensonhurst. Bonanno Captain Cesare Bonventre was observed, as were automobiles registered to Vincent D'Ambrosio (66y) and Salvatore Patafio (52y). Bonventre was followed from the cafe to Mirabile's One Eleven Social Club. Agents noted automobiles registered to Vincent Napoli (69y) and Gennaro Vitelli (55y) parked outside the club. (D'Ambrosio [1913-1983] resided in South Cairo, New York. Patafio [1928-2010], a resident of Long Island, was from Scilla in Reggio Calabria. Napoli [1910-] and Vitelli [1925-2008] resided in Gravesend and LI respectively.)
On September 12, 1980 FBI surveillance conducted on the One Eleven Social Club. Observations included automobiles registered to Frank Antico (58y), Anthony Causi (65y), Vincent Napoli (69y), Anthony Vaccaro (63y) and Gennaro Vitelli (55y). (Antico [1922-2000] lived in New Springville, Staten Island. Causi [1915-1981] and Vaccaro [1917-1981) were Gravesend residents.)
On September 22, 1980 the FBI's New York Office reported: "[Agent] advised that Salvatore Mirabile, aka 'Toddo' Mirabile, is in Cesare Bonventre's crew. Mirabile allegedly is a big money maker for Bonventre. Mirabile operates a social club located at 2525 W. 17th Street, Brooklyn."
By 1980 made members of Bonventre's crew included Baldassare 'Baldo' Amato, Louis 'Louie Ha-Ha' Attanasio, Frank Bonomo, John 'Johnny Green' Faraci, James Genna, Frank Lupo, Salvatore Mirabile and Robert 'Bobby Bad Heart' Perrette.
Possible crew members included Salvatore 'Sal Longo' Caccamise and Santo 'Toni' Giordano. (Caccamise may not have been made at the time. CW Salvatore Vitale later testified that he believed Giordano was Bonventre's Acting Captain circa May 1981.)
In January 1980 included in the FBI's list of 119 identified Bonanno Family members.
By Summer 1980 operated the One Eleven Social Club at West 17th and Bay 50th Sts in Gravesend.
On September 11, 1980 FBI surveillance conducted on Caffe Roma in Bensonhurst. Bonanno Captain Cesare Bonventre was observed, as were automobiles registered to Vincent D'Ambrosio (66y) and Salvatore Patafio (52y). Bonventre was followed from the cafe to Mirabile's One Eleven Social Club. Agents noted automobiles registered to Vincent Napoli (69y) and Gennaro Vitelli (55y) parked outside the club. (D'Ambrosio [1913-1983] resided in South Cairo, New York. Patafio [1928-2010], a resident of Long Island, was from Scilla in Reggio Calabria. Napoli [1910-] and Vitelli [1925-2008] resided in Gravesend and LI respectively.)
On September 12, 1980 FBI surveillance conducted on the One Eleven Social Club. Observations included automobiles registered to Frank Antico (58y), Anthony Causi (65y), Vincent Napoli (69y), Anthony Vaccaro (63y) and Gennaro Vitelli (55y). (Antico [1922-2000] lived in New Springville, Staten Island. Causi [1915-1981] and Vaccaro [1917-1981) were Gravesend residents.)
On September 22, 1980 the FBI's New York Office reported: "[Agent] advised that Salvatore Mirabile, aka 'Toddo' Mirabile, is in Cesare Bonventre's crew. Mirabile allegedly is a big money maker for Bonventre. Mirabile operates a social club located at 2525 W. 17th Street, Brooklyn."
 |
| Bono Wedding (11/80) Top Row (L to R): Baldassare Amato, Jack Mirabile (Salvatore's brother) Bottom Row (L to R): Cesare Bonventre, Salvatore Mirabile, Salvatore Caccamise |
On November 16, 1980 Sicilian Mafia Member Giuseppe Bono married in New York. Many LCN figures attended the reception, including Cesare Bonventre and crew members Frank Bonomo and Salvatore Mirabile.
On January 6, 1981 FBI CI reported: "[Cesare] Bonventre is a Capo in the Bonanno LCN Family [and] Toddo Mirabile and [Redacted] are assigned to Bonventre's crew."
In early 1982 an Unspecified Male, in debt to several loansharks including Mirabile, reached out to the FBI and agreed to wear a wire. Mirabile was designated the subject of an Extortionate Credit Transaction (ECT) investigation.
On March 9, 1982 erroneously identified by FBI as 'a shylock and known member of the Genovese Family of organized crime'.
In September 1982 included in the FBI's list of identified Bonanno Family members.
Included in the June 1983 Senate Chart of Bonanno membership.
In early April 1984 Mirabile's Captain Cesare Bonventre was murdered and succeeded by Louis Attanasio.
On January 6, 1981 FBI CI reported: "[Cesare] Bonventre is a Capo in the Bonanno LCN Family [and] Toddo Mirabile and [Redacted] are assigned to Bonventre's crew."
In early 1982 an Unspecified Male, in debt to several loansharks including Mirabile, reached out to the FBI and agreed to wear a wire. Mirabile was designated the subject of an Extortionate Credit Transaction (ECT) investigation.
On March 9, 1982 erroneously identified by FBI as 'a shylock and known member of the Genovese Family of organized crime'.
In September 1982 included in the FBI's list of identified Bonanno Family members.
Included in the June 1983 Senate Chart of Bonanno membership.
In early April 1984 Mirabile's Captain Cesare Bonventre was murdered and succeeded by Louis Attanasio.
 |
| D'Amico Reception (June 1984) Top: Sal Mirabile (R) and his new Captain Louis Attanasio (L) Bottom: Salvatore's son John Mirabile |
On June 2, 1984 Bonanno Soldier Joseph D'Amico married. Attendees at the reception, held at St. Regis Hotel in Midtown, included:
Louis Attanasio (Bonanno [Acting?] Captain)
John Gotti (Gambino Acting Captain) [Acting for Carmine Fatico]
Gabriel Infanti (Bonanno Captain)
Frank Lino (Bonanno Acting Captain)
Anthony Spero (Bonanno Acting Captain)
Frank Coppa (Bonanno Soldier) [Lino Crew]
Pasquale 'Patty Box Cars' Cosoleto (Bonanno Soldier) [Spero Crew?]
Gerald 'Jerry' Chilli (Bonanno Soldier)
Joseph Chilli (Bonanno Soldier) [Spero Crew]
Frank DeCicco (Gambino Soldier) [Riccobono Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Alfred 'Al Walker' Embarrato (Bonanno Soldier) [Episcopia Crew]
Anthony 'T.G' Graziano (Bonanno Soldier)
Anthony 'Tony Lee' Guerrieri (Gambino Soldier) [Fatico / Gotti Crew]
Anthony 'Bruno' Indelicato (Bonanno Soldier) [Massino Crew]
Frank 'Frankie Loc' LoCascio (Gambino Soldier) [Zingaro Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Salvatore 'Toto' Mirabile (Bonanno Soldier) [Attanasio Crew]
Anthony 'Fish' Rabito (Bonanno Soldier)
William 'Big Willie' Riviello (Bonanno Soldier) [Infanti Crew]
Paul 'Paulie Zac' Zaccaria (Gambino Soldier) [Garofalo Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Richard 'Shellackhead' Cantarella (Bonanno Associate) [Episcopia Crew]
Angelo D'Amico (Bonanno Associate) [Lino Crew] [Father to Joseph]
Ronald 'Monkey Man' Filocomo (Bonanno Associate) [Lino Crew]
John 'Johnny Boy' Mirabile (Bonanno Associate) [Attanasio Crew]
John Gotti (Gambino Acting Captain) [Acting for Carmine Fatico]
Gabriel Infanti (Bonanno Captain)
Frank Lino (Bonanno Acting Captain)
Anthony Spero (Bonanno Acting Captain)
Frank Coppa (Bonanno Soldier) [Lino Crew]
Pasquale 'Patty Box Cars' Cosoleto (Bonanno Soldier) [Spero Crew?]
Gerald 'Jerry' Chilli (Bonanno Soldier)
Joseph Chilli (Bonanno Soldier) [Spero Crew]
Frank DeCicco (Gambino Soldier) [Riccobono Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Alfred 'Al Walker' Embarrato (Bonanno Soldier) [Episcopia Crew]
Anthony 'T.G' Graziano (Bonanno Soldier)
Anthony 'Tony Lee' Guerrieri (Gambino Soldier) [Fatico / Gotti Crew]
Anthony 'Bruno' Indelicato (Bonanno Soldier) [Massino Crew]
Frank 'Frankie Loc' LoCascio (Gambino Soldier) [Zingaro Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Salvatore 'Toto' Mirabile (Bonanno Soldier) [Attanasio Crew]
Anthony 'Fish' Rabito (Bonanno Soldier)
William 'Big Willie' Riviello (Bonanno Soldier) [Infanti Crew]
Paul 'Paulie Zac' Zaccaria (Gambino Soldier) [Garofalo Crew] [Possibly Acting Captain]
Richard 'Shellackhead' Cantarella (Bonanno Associate) [Episcopia Crew]
Angelo D'Amico (Bonanno Associate) [Lino Crew] [Father to Joseph]
Ronald 'Monkey Man' Filocomo (Bonanno Associate) [Lino Crew]
John 'Johnny Boy' Mirabile (Bonanno Associate) [Attanasio Crew]
In 1988 included in Senate list of 94 identified Bonanno Family members.
Salvatore Mirabile died on September 23, 1991.
His son John is believed to have been inducted into the Bonanno Family the same year.